In some ways, it could confirm why Valvoline doesn’t market their oils for extended drains as some engines may suffer deposits like this from extended service. Everything seems fine until oil consumption starts to increase. UOAs have limits in their usefulness to see evidence of change in the piston ring areas.
That said, it’s possible this could happen even on a boutique oil though less likely as they are formulated for extended service. It would’ve been interesting to see if Amsoil Signature Series kept consumption down with regular use prior, but all the same for ESP as the guinea pig; though by comparison is it marketed as an extended service life oil?