Al Capone once said: "You can get further with a smile & and a gun than you can get with a smile alone"....that being a given, you can have ALL of the 22's 25's 32's & 380's and yes, you can kill someone deader than the proverbial doorknob with any of them, but the fact remains, that with the types of drugs on the street today that inhibit both fear AND pain reaction, the person you shoot with any of these will most likely die.....after he kills you. They simply do not do enough damage.
Most of the Ultra-lite 357's are largely worthless, not enough barrel to burn the powder and too much recoil to control. The same is pretty much true with 38+p from a snub, too much slow-burning powder and not enough barrel. I have seen 2 cases where folks firing the full-house 125 gr 357 load from a 10 oz revolver have broken bones in their hands.
I have carried a S&W Airweight 38 since the 60's and was in Law Enforcement (as a backup) and used either 110 gr or 125 gr loads (non +P) with the rationale that 5 controlled center-mass hits are better than a peripheral hit and 4 misses. I carry a S&W 642 with the Federal 110 gr reduced recoil loads or the new Hornady 125 gr when I can get them. This is my "light" gun. I prefer a full sized M1911 as a "serious" gun, however they are a bit too heavy for daily carry. I also have a Glock M23 in 40 S&W,
most law enforcement journals have documented the 40 S&W as having essentially the same index of incapacitation as the 45, 13 rounds instead of 7 and less recoil to boot. I have shot the Kahr pistols in both 9 & 40 and they do well and are well made.
I agree with most of what you said. BUT a .45 ACP is better than a .40S&W cartridge and is documented now by SOCOM...Marine Elite Forces and The FBI SWAT Hostage Rescue Teams that are trained by Marines.
-The FBI Hostage Rescue Team has adopted the Springfield Professional 1911 .45 ACP as their gun.
http://springfield-armory.primediaoutdoors.com/SPstory06.php
-Marine Expditiary Elite Forces have gone to the 1911 Springer Professional .45 ACP as well.
-SOCOM has put in an order for several thousand Springfield Operator 1911's .45 ACP to replace Beretta 9mm's and Sig .40's
-LAPD SWAT uses Custom 1911's .45 ACP as well.
Most "Elite" LE agencies in the US are back to the .45 ACP. A big circle strating at the .38 special...then the 9mm...then the FBI going to the 10mm...back to the .40 S&W and the "Elite Teams" in LE and Military going back to the .45 ACP.
Germany is all HK .45 ACP. South America is all 1911 .45 ACP as is most of Asia
It's a fact that 230 gr .45 ball ammo in studies does as well (penetration and lack of it is what the FBI says is what gets you killed) as .40 S&W "designer" hollow points and in some instances better. Winchester Bonded Ammo used by the FBI SWAT Teams outperforms .40 S&W by a wide margin. Why else would they insist on a $ 3,000.00 Springfield professional .45 ACP? They want the best of everything acorss the board.
Why the .40 S&W to begin with? It's all about cost folks and finding a weapon for the "masses to be able to control and shoot" as there were too many instances of 9mm killings of LE officers.. It is a middle of the road caliber that most can manage with good stopping power if you can aim.
Any questions? Ask McArthur!