What base model 4x4 truck would you buy?

You can get a regular cab long bed Ram 1500 Classic with 3.55 gears and some creature comforts (limited slip diff, cloth seats, keyless entry that kind of stuff) added for $43k MSRP and that’ll get you a tow rating of ~7,000lbs. A v8 puts you at $46k.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JTK
You could also get a Sport Trim Ridgeline it'll tow 5000 and probably be pretty easy to live with, for 45 you should even be able to get an HPD if that interest you.

I did the whole midsize/full size comparison a few years ago, at least with respect to Fords you'll save 7-8000 on a ranger if you prices and equip them similarly. The new Ranger is slightly larger than the old one and supposedly a sheet of plywood will lay flat in the bed now. Long McArthur has some good videos on the trucks that break them down by trim.

Frankly i said id get a Super cab 6.5 bed XL with FX4 (locking diff) but in truth for the difference in money id probably get an STX which has become its own trim in 2024 with FX4 and a few other carefully selected options. That would put you over 45 sticker, you might be able to buy one for that though...

Any of the full size 4x4 trucks are going to be pushing the 45 mark...
 
I’m not spending a lot of money on some piece of crap that’s uncomfortable. I sold my new Tesla 2 years ago because of that 😉

The Jeep has Corbeau seats on order at the moment.
Dr. Evil said it best.

You just don’t get it, do you?
 
Theres absolutely no point in buying a mid size. For the same money you can buy a full size which can tow more , more comfortable, in some cases better gas milage , more room for fam etc. besides Tacomas suck , worst seat ever and worst engines ever.
Mid sized trucks are far better off road. Otherwise I mostly agree.
 
Would a midsize fit better in the typical garage? Camry fits well in mine, but anything much larger is a problem. [My side does have a workbench stealing a couple of feet, but anything tall is going to smash into the door opener if I lift any amount.
 
I like my 2021 Ranger XL Supercab 4x4 with tow package and locking rear diff. It cost me $31k out the door. Towing is rated at 7000 lbs. I tow 3000 pretty regularly with ease. The ride of the base Ranger isn't bad either. And it's pretty quick.

As I mentioned in another thread, the newer Rangers are about the same size as the F-150s of 20 years ago.
 
I like my 2021 Ranger XL Supercab 4x4 with tow package and locking rear diff. It cost me $31k out the door. Towing is rated at 7000 lbs. I tow 3000 pretty regularly with ease. The ride of the base Ranger isn't bad either. And it's pretty quick.

As I mentioned in another thread, the newer Rangers are about the same size as the F-150s of 20 years ago.

Your tow rating is 7500. All Rangers are rated to tow 7500 with a receiver hitch.*

*Unless it is the 2024 Raptor, those are rated to tow less.
 
Would a midsize fit better in the typical garage? Camry fits well in mine, but anything much larger is a problem. [My side does have a workbench stealing a couple of feet, but anything tall is going to smash into the door opener if I lift any amount.

Yes. Easier to maneuver, easier to park, etc ,etc.

Ford did choose to put a big stupid tall antenna on top though, so I replaced mine with a stubby, mainly so I didn't have to remove the OEM one when running through the car wash, but I could see the factory one getting hung on a low garage door too.
 
Given your price range and wants, I would pick the Chevy Colorado LT 4x4. Go with the 2.7 HO engine option.
 
Last edited:
And what’s wrong with the Tacoma engine? I admit I haven’t been paying attention but I always thought Toyota built great engines. What happened?

Nothing really. People just don't know how to put their foot into it. They can't let go of the old 4.0. While it was a great engine, it wheezed out fairly early compared to the 3.5. I've owned two of both and they both have their pluses and minuses. The 3rd gen is BITOG's favorite truck to bash!
 
My pickup fits the description perfectly, and its plenty nice as a DD.

4wd f150 supercab, 2.7L, 36gal fuel tank, AC, power locks and windows. They added bucket seats and the 7” sync radio. They marked 5k off when I bought it for a total of 36k new in 2018. granted, if you were only using it occasionally, I’d favor the base NA v6, because the eco is complex and vehicles need to be driven - I would wager the base v6 would be more tolerant of the “occasional use” cycle. If I recall, at new pricing the eco was a $2k cost, so an XL extended cab with the base v6 would be even less expensive.

the 4 doors have the market flooded. I recall one dealership had 119 4 doors on the lot, and 2 extended cabs - so you would have to look around a bit. Chances are also, you’ll have 2 color choices - white and gray.
 
Say you’re someone who needs a truck for occasional farm and off-road use, so it needs to be 4x4. And say you often tow a 1300 pound (total) aluminum boat. And say you very rarely need to tow a 4000 pound tractor, but only for five miles. And you occasionally haul stuff, so a six foot or longer bed would be nice.

If your goal is to get the most frugal new vehicle that could accomplish these without being overly stressed, what brand/model truck would you choose? Either mid or full size is fine. I didn’t say compact because those don’t actually exist anymore.

Let’s say $45k is the absolute maximum spending cap but
Are you talking new or used?
45K cash or financed?
 
I like the Frontier myself. I've also seen some Ram Classic V6s in the mid 30's brand new
One of our family friends owns a 500 acre farm. He has always owned base model single cab long bed trucks just for daily driver/general farm duty. He just got a new Ram, and for being a base model it's actually a pretty nice truck and perfect for what he needs without the interior feeling like you bought the rental fleet model.
 
Back
Top Bottom