How many miles on yours and please share the last couple OCIs oil brands and grades.
I'm at about 60,000 miles. I factory ordered the truck, changed the oil twice within the first 7500 miles using dealer oil.
At 15,000 I switched to better oils (sorted by date):
Redline 5w-30
Redline 5w-20
Redline 5w-30
Redline 0w-30
Mobil 1 FS 0w-40
HPL PP 0w-30
HPL no vii Euro 5w-30
HPL PCMO 5w-20
Been kind of all over the map for a few reasons. I had pretty significant top end chattering noises on dealer oil which got me started looking for a solution and trying if oil would help. That googling led me to Burla's posts here and on ramforum and experimenting with Redline. I never had "hemi tick", but in general the engine (that specific noise) quieted down almost immediately on Redline and has stayed that way through the other oil changes.
I also had a cold start knocking that I could not get rid of. Especially in the winter it would make a "piston slap"(?) noise until it warmed up after a few minutes it would be completely gone. When it was hot it was buttery smooth, but cold starts in the summer as well though perhaps less signficantly, I'd have that noise for a few minutes.
I believe I noticed it first sometime after switching to Redline, and nothing has silenced that until the current run of HPL PCMO 5w-20. It was doing it on RL 5w-20 as well (which is why I tested it to rule out viscosity). I tried various 0 weights to help in the winter starts, I tried the premium plus due to its exceptional cold start properties, nothing worked.
But the last few months on PCMO 5w-20 its pretty much gone so I'm very happy with that. Piston slap? Who knows. I just know that I've never been happier than on my current oil and if that's all just a figment of my imagination then so be it.
There is one difference between my current oil and the others, it's a group 3 base. I don't know if that's significant or coincidental, or completely irrelevant but I'm just throwing it out there.
I have enough oil for one more run of no vii 5w-30, but plan to stick with HPL and move to PCMO 5w-30 long term.