Someone created a youtube comparing M1 0W-20 AFE and Kirkland same weight. Used M1 for first 150,000 miles at 10K intervals in his Toyota, then decided to do some comparisons, sending samples in for analysis. While this is one car and one owners use, I find it illuminating.
M1 vs Kirkland!
- Thread starter srfdude
- Start date
Is the Costco oil better, or is the Mobil 1 worse........ that is the question?
- Joined
- Oct 25, 2021
- Messages
- 1,236
AFE isn’t anything special. It’s still M1 but eh.Is the Costco oil better, or is the Mobil 1 worse........ that is the question?
Virtually no difference.
OVERKILL
$100 Site Donor 2021
Looks like he needs to use a lab that properly measures fuel, that 1.3% is more like 4%.
What does one expect to see? UOA's aren't a tool designed to facilitate the comparison of oils to each other, simply confirm the health of the equipment and the oil's suitability for continued use.
What does one expect to see? UOA's aren't a tool designed to facilitate the comparison of oils to each other, simply confirm the health of the equipment and the oil's suitability for continued use.
I guess the other thread is right. Oil is oil.
These two certainly very close in THIS application. Again, to me points out the proposition as............skeptical. It's not such a binary thing.
I agree that the primary role of a UOA is the health of the equipment. Having said that, since both oils are D1-G3 (now), and the add packs are virtually identical, whats left? Perhaps deposits/varnish which this won't tell. But after 10K,the residual oil properties may be slightly shaded to Kirkland, or just call them even, indicating that perhaps 10K, at least on that Toyota, is a reasonable oil life for both oils.
What does D1 and G3 mean?
BrendanC
$100 site donor 2024
gm dexos 1 gen 3. latest oil spec from gm.
Well almost but look at the flashpoints. But then those test are 30,000 miles apart as well.
Duh brains not functioning today.. LOL.. since when do we compare oils, via UOA? Isn't that meant to tell us how our engine is doing
OVERKILL
$100 Site Donor 2021
Yes, similar LSPI-compliant metal constituents to the additive packages, but we don't know how those are delivered or what non-metallics are present either.
As I said in the other thread, using a UOA to try and compare oils is like stabbing your eyes out with an ice pick and then trying to judge a beauty pageant.
4WD
$50 site donor 2024
First thing to catch my eye are the perfect mileage readings …
They must pull over and catch samples on the road shoulder
They must pull over and catch samples on the road shoulder
4WD
$50 site donor 2024
This is simultaneously funny and disturbing... I don't understand the statement, but thank you for keeping this thread interesting.
