I and my son had to make car buying decisions for my 2 SIL's (68 and 72 years old). One lives in rural Kansas the other in a larger city in Ohio. The one in Ohio we suggested and she bought a new RAV4 Hybrid. It took some convincing as she didn't fully understand the technology). 90% of her driving is going to pick up her grandkids every day to put them on and off the school bus. It's 3 miles one way and she can do a big chunk of that on battery power alone. She regularly gets 40+ mpg and likes all the room for the car seats and back packs. However, on a couple of trips from Ohio to Kansas she only got 32 to 34 mpg. My SIL in Kansas liked that 40 mpg her sister got, but 90% of her driving is on highways to get to towns for Walmart runs, etc. (often 20 + miles or more away). I convinced her to get a normally aspirated car (rather than a hybrid). As a result, her mpg is as good as or slightly better than her sisters hybrid on the highway and cost her less to buy. She takes a small hit driving around town which isn't too frequent. Both seem to be very happy. Different solutions for different circumstances.