Do you like the car? Is it what your wife wants to drive?
There is so much more to cars than just the engine. Yeah sure, it's important - but ... Back a few years, all Volvos and Jag's consumed a qt every 1,000 miles. If they did not, you knew you were in some trouble. I've gotten over 300,000 miles out of engines that consume 1 qt/1,000.
Oil is so cheap compared to the price of a car, why are you sweating this? Do you think it's because the engine is going to fail? It won't, it will run until you are sick and tired of it.
If it's a valve seal, it'll get worse. How long is the warranty? They will replace it sometime, just not now ... Keep good records.
Is your warranty void is you get it serviced at an independent shop? What does a 4-banger Camry cylinder head overhaul cost now days? I'll bet it could all be done for $2K at say 50,000 miles and driven on for another 250,000. Amortized over the life of the vehicle, it's pocket change ...