Originally Posted By: gathermewool
Again, every application is different. A mineral oil with a good additive package may suffice in a low boost, relatively low stress turbo-charged engine, where as a stouter oil may be more prudent in a high-boost, high hp/liter application.
Personally, I feel that even though I didn't burn any oil using the API-SM Cam2 oil, that a synthetic oil with lower volatility than the max required by GF-5/SN, as well as better oxidative resistance, higher viscosity, and an additive package that may possibly lean toward a more aggressive anti-wear package is beneficial, even for some one with a short interval.
Furthermore, all it takes in an engine with high cylinder pressures is one good knock event to cause damage. If not actual damage to the piston, then maybe in the form of a spun bearing. While no oil can prevent spinning a bearing should you have massive amounts of knock, it is my belief that an oil with high HTHS (stable viscosity, even in areas of the motor experiencing high temperatures,) and an overall better additive package than those oils limited to GF-5 or SN (resource conserving) additive levels for emissions control systems reasons.
In the end, if you drive as gently as you say you do, then choosing something like Mobil Super will probably be just fine, but I'd not sleep well at night unless I sent out a sample after 3-4k to ensure that I'm not experiencing oil-killing fuel dilution or any unusual trends caused by driving mostly gently combined with occasional romps.
Actually ran into a friend today who now works at Tires Plus/Tire Kingdom. He drives an EVO. Well, we got on the subject discussed here and i mentioned i just changed my oil and it was to conventional. He extended the offer to change my oil for this one time, free, to Kendall GT1 semi-syn 5w30. He said, as you have, that he understands i may be ok with the conventional but (btw) Tires Plus/Tire kingdom charges the same for an oil change using semi syn Kendall GT1 as Mobil Lube Express does using Mobil conventional. He did see in his computer that conventional is required but didnt care. Filter? same, just repackaged Mobil M2808 / Champion PF2808. 3,750 OCI. So, that is what i did.