Originally Posted By: PandaBear
Originally Posted By: friendly_jacek
So pandabear, you say hondas never brake and batteries always need to be replaced in prius? Last time I checked, tranny in honda was more expensive to replace than battery in prius.
I never said that. However, most Honda's manual transmission are reliable (if you get the CVT insight that's a different story, as manual has the lean burn engine that CVT does not have).
Tranny in a small civic sized car should be very cheap when it dies due to age, and manual on small Honda doesn't have design issue that V6 Honda auto has. I highly doubt a rebuild honda civic manual tranny should be $2-3k in parts (san installation as both battery and swapping tranny need installation labor).
Or you can swap in a junk yard totaled manual tranny and call it a day, if you are unlucky that the manual civic tranny die.
The rest of the cars compare similarly between Prius and Insight / Civic.
Nothing stops one from buying used $500 battery or rebuilding it for $50-100 rather than paying the retail $2000 for a new one. Battery failures are incredibly rare in prius. Unfortunately, not something you can say about honda.
Originally Posted By: friendly_jacek
So pandabear, you say hondas never brake and batteries always need to be replaced in prius? Last time I checked, tranny in honda was more expensive to replace than battery in prius.
I never said that. However, most Honda's manual transmission are reliable (if you get the CVT insight that's a different story, as manual has the lean burn engine that CVT does not have).
Tranny in a small civic sized car should be very cheap when it dies due to age, and manual on small Honda doesn't have design issue that V6 Honda auto has. I highly doubt a rebuild honda civic manual tranny should be $2-3k in parts (san installation as both battery and swapping tranny need installation labor).
Or you can swap in a junk yard totaled manual tranny and call it a day, if you are unlucky that the manual civic tranny die.
The rest of the cars compare similarly between Prius and Insight / Civic.
Nothing stops one from buying used $500 battery or rebuilding it for $50-100 rather than paying the retail $2000 for a new one. Battery failures are incredibly rare in prius. Unfortunately, not something you can say about honda.