PUP vs Shell gas & truck

[Scott S]

I read something the other day, that sales were better on 5W30 Pennzoil ultra Platinum, then Shell gas and truck, so they discontinued Shell gas and truck, but it also went on to state that according to VOA'S they are virtually the same oils.
I did a search I was unable to find current VOA's on both of them oils..

Thank you.

 

[dubber09]

https://bobistheoilguy.com/forums/threads/pennzoil-ultra-platinum-5w30.323940/
https://www.ramforum.com/threads/shell-rotella-gas-truck-oil-analysis.187163/

googled in 1 min

 

[wpod]

Which oil would let your engine out last your ownership of the vehicle? [Either one.]

 

[Scott S]

Not too close...

 

[Scott S]

Which oil would let your engine out last your ownership of the vehicle? [Either one.]

Most definitely, but Shell gas and truck they don't even manufacture anymore.. I'm running 5W-20 now and I'm thinking of going to a 5W-30.

 

[02zx9r rev2]

Most definitely, but Shell gas and truck they don't even manufacture anymore..

PUP it is then

 

[4WD]

I have one jug (of many) of RGT left - it’s a generation back …

 

[02zx9r rev2]

I have one jug (of many) of RGT left - it’s a generation back …

3 left. Should of gotten more when had the chance

 

[Scott S]

Unfortunately I never had a chance to run it, I wish I did.. I heard it was really good oil..

 

[02zx9r rev2]

From what I’ve read and from uoa’s, it wasn’t a long drain interval oil. Ok for 5000 ish mile oci

 

[4WD]

From what I’ve read and from uoa’s, it wasn’t a long drain interval oil. Ok for 5000 ish mile oci

Yes, CarbonSteel was holding to 5k bcs TBN was meh …
I do 5k too - like to get under the Jeep and look around …

 

[addyguy]

Got 1 jug left of 5W-30 that will go in the wife’s Jeep for the summer probably.

 

[THORROMIG]

I have one 5qt jug of 5W30 left and 19 quarts of 0W20 still from Advance Auto multiple years back clearance.

 

[kschachn]

Unfortunately I never had a chance to run it, I wish I did.. I heard it was really good oil..

If that is your selection criteria then there are other oils discussed on Facebook which are described as "really good oil".

 

[Scott S]

If that is your selection criteria then there are other oils discussed on Facebook which are described as "really good oil".

It was just something I wanted to try out.

 

[Merek]

The RGT was good oil but nothing stellar by any means and used an additive package that was slightly different from QS and from the comments on here it was actually more comparable but the QS did have higher moly content in comparison.