Maybe not for a full minute, but for about the first 15-30 seconds, my engines used to sound like the pistons were changing holes when started at -40 or better with 5w30 (1990's dino formulations).quote:
Originally posted by kev99sl:
... drain all of the oil out of your engine, let the car sit overnight with the drain plug out, and then start it up the next morning and drive it gently as you did the day before, again listening carefully to your engine for about a minute. Does it really sound the same as it did the day before?
Then where does that noise come from?quote:
I don't think "lack of oil flow" is that big of a problem in the cold.
Yup, been there before. Melted a starter when I didn't realize that the block heater cord wasn't making contact at -44. Solenoid relay welded shut, while the engine turned at about 10 rpm, and by the time I could retrieve a wrench to disconnect the battery, all the smoke had been let out of the starter.quote:
If it was that much of a problem, I'm not sure you could even turn the engine over.
I think the right answer is it depends. Under the conditions that 99% of Americans encounter 99% of the time, a 15 second warm up is more than adequate when combined with gentle driving. However, when pushing the limits of your lubricants, I think it makes sense to warm things SOME with as little load on the bearings as possible. I would wager that it takes as much power to move a COLD vehicle down the road at 30 mph as it does to move a fully warm vehicle at 60. I've seen vehicles at the end of a tow chain sliding all 4 wheels in the snow from the drag of the cold drivetrain. In that case, I think A LITTLE idling becomes the lesser of the evils.