I've run nitrile for 6k without issue in my 2008 Jeep 3.8. If the drainback valve fails, I get plenty of noise on cold starts. I know this because 2008-era Mobil 1 filters for this application had an anti drainback valve that didn't work at the angle at which this engine's filter is mounted. It was a well known issue. I switched to Motorcraft and later Fram filters, but ran a few cheapos here and there with nitrile valves and they never failed. I've run Fram Ultras to 18k (3 OCI's) on it with no issue, but those are all silicone, at least for now.