Amsoil 0W30 or 5W30 for new Pontiac G8 GT?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted By: OVERK1LL

I am unfamiliar with that history. I know VERY little about Amsoil comparatively, because I am a long-time M1 user and have never really had a reason to switch....


I guess there is even earlier bad blood than this....Al really tweaked off GM. Al was presenting a discussion, at an SAE meeting, on extended oil drains at a meeting. Someone from GM Lubricants Division took exception to his comments.

Al asked how many engineers GM had on the payroll. The guy couldn't answer, so Al prodded--3,000? 5,000? 8,000?
Al said something about none of them knew anything about lubricants, and they couldn't design a car on which the spark plugs couldn't be changed without lifting the engine.

About that time, the GM guys get redfaced and stomped out of the meeting.

Shortly thereafter, Al learned about the NOACK test, which was only being done in Europe at the time. He had Lubrizol run some tests in their lab in England. He published the results, which showed that the GM Goodwrench oil had the worst results. The GM guys called Lubrizol, and asked if they had seen what that S*O*B Amatuzio had published. Lubrizol guys said they had seen it, and their own tests confirmed it. Within 2-3 weeks, GM had a new OEM supplier (Mobil)

There was some enmity between some of the participants for a number of years. Since then, I suspect all the GM side have retired and/or died, and Al keeps plugging.
 
Originally Posted By: Pablo
Originally Posted By: OVERK1LL

I am unfamiliar with that history. I know VERY little about Amsoil comparatively, because I am a long-time M1 user and have never really had a reason to switch....


I guess there is even earlier bad blood than this....Al really tweaked off GM. Al was presenting a discussion, at an SAE meeting, on extended oil drains at a meeting. Someone from GM Lubricants Division took exception to his comments.

Al asked how many engineers GM had on the payroll. The guy couldn't answer, so Al prodded--3,000? 5,000? 8,000?
Al said something about none of them knew anything about lubricants, and they couldn't design a car on which the spark plugs couldn't be changed without lifting the engine.

About that time, the GM guys get redfaced and stomped out of the meeting.

Shortly thereafter, Al learned about the NOACK test, which was only being done in Europe at the time. He had Lubrizol run some tests in their lab in England. He published the results, which showed that the GM Goodwrench oil had the worst results. The GM guys called Lubrizol, and asked if they had seen what that S*O*B Amatuzio had published. Lubrizol guys said they had seen it, and their own tests confirmed it. Within 2-3 weeks, GM had a new OEM supplier (Mobil)

There was some enmity between some of the participants for a number of years. Since then, I suspect all the GM side have retired and/or died, and Al keeps plugging.


That is bloody hilarious!!!!!!! Not being a GM fan, that warms my heart
wink.gif
HAHAHAHAHA

I will cut open my PureONE when I'm done with it here and take some pics. We can compare it to the EaO when I finally pull it off. I haven't sent in my bloody dealer app form yet, it's just sitting here, I'll do that tomorrow.

-Chris
 
Quote:
I LOVE THAT CAR! too bad my [censored] would bleed every time I had to fill her up :P


Why, I get 25+ MPG on highway trips averaging 75+mph. Awesome mileage for the HP.
 
Nice car-and even nicer color, BTW my 13 year old 5.7 LT1 vette runs 13.2 @ 109, on M1 5-30- 13 yo plugs and wires too. Supposedly 300 hp, but I sincerely doubt it
 
Regarding those that have said only the M1 would pass certain GM tests... 2 of my vehicles have factory rec's for a 5w-30 synthetic oil. One of them is a supercharged 4 cylinder pushing 129+hp/liter, the other a new, large 7.0L V8 with 505 or so HP. Both cars previously used M1 5w-30.

Based on my experience with the s/c 4cyl using M1 (this car is fairly tough on the oil), with many short street trips with incomplete oil warm up (about 140-150f) & then trips to the race track where it would see sustained high loads from plenty of full throttle high RPM blasts lasting ~20-30 minutes per session (oil temps of ~260-280f), and repeated 6-8 times per weekend, with 6k OCI's. After a few k miles & 1 track event I would notice some increased engine noise & roughness. By oil change time, UOA's showed some shearing/thinning and the M1 went to a rather low 30w. There was only minimal fuel dilution too, not as much as many direct injection cars, so that shouldn't have been a problem. I switched to Amsoil (which I had tried in another track car & bike) and the engine retained it's typical "new oil change" quietness for the entire OCI. The UOA's showed less thinning and a _very_ slight decrease in wear, even though I left it in slightly longer.

Based on results with that vehicle, I decided to try Amsoil in my LS7 as well. 1 or 2 GM/M1 loyalists on the Z06 boards have practically screamed bloody murder saying that I should be running M1 "as it's what GM rec's", but none have showed me any data to explain why they feel it's "supposedly" better than Amsoil.

Since I've found the Amsoil held up better in another application that called for the same 5w-30 as my Z06, why would I want to run the M1 since I it wasn't as good as some other oils available when really pushed?
 
If you go with AMsoil get their Series 3000 5W30 HDEO it is the best they make in my opion for your application!
 
Originally Posted By: JohnBrowning
If you go with AMsoil get their Series 3000 5W30 HDEO it is the best they make in my opion for your application!


Actually this is outdated information. I would not recommend the Amsoil HDD for this application ahead of SSO. HDD would do OK in wear, I'm sure, but I don't think a high SAPS oil is needed or called for.
 
Quote:
Nice car-and even nicer color, BTW my 13 year old 5.7 LT1 vette runs 13.2 @ 109, on M1 5-30- 13 yo plugs and wires too. Supposedly 300 hp, but I sincerely doubt it


Good times for a 1995 LT1 Corvette, so good in fact that I would have to see it to believe it.
crackmeup2.gif
But I see you are in New Jersey. Must be Atco times with frigid air! Bring that LT1 to Phoenix and let me see it go 14's. 6spd or auto?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom