Agreed. I see the thread was necro'd and didn't read the whole thing but this debate is like less filling vs tastes great.
It makes sense to me solder can crack in time, esp in the conditions vehicles see (vibration, constant movement, heat etc). We see this fairly often in failed modules and circuit boards in vehicles in fact.
It also makes sense to me that a properly executed mechanical connection such as crimping will prove more durable than solder.
If the opposite makes sense to others, that's ok -- they should use solder and the world won't end. I like blondes more than brunettes so I choose crimps whenever possible