Porsche Admits Trouble Ahead: “Our Business Model No Longer Works”

Joined
Nov 16, 2002
Messages
40,131
Location
NJ
Per Autoblog 07/24/25

Bumpy road ahead for a lot of automakers. A lot of uncertainty due to tariffs, EV's and changing geopolitical issues.

"Porsche has warned employees that its current business model “no longer works,” as the company braces for cost-cutting talks amid falling profits, China struggles, and EV headwinds.

CEO Oliver Blume told employees that the company’s traditional business model is no longer sustainable in the current climate. “Our business model, which has served us well for many decades, no longer works in its current form,” Blume said.

This sobering admission sets the tone for a forthcoming round of cost-cutting talks, with Porsche now preparing for a serious overhaul of its production structure, spending priorities, and long-term strategy. Labor negotiations are expected to begin later this year — and if the last round of restructuring is anything to go by, the fallout could be substantial.

North America Up, China Down

To the casual observer, this warning might seem surprising. After all, Porsche’s North American division just posted its best-ever half-year sales figures. Deliveries rose 11.4% year-over-year, with 38,696 vehicles shifted in just six months. CEO of Porsche Cars North America, Timo Resch, credited the growth to customer enthusiasm and the strength of the dealer network.

But the bigger picture is far less rosy. Globally, Porsche is still down 8% on sales in Q1, and much of that downturn is being driven by a stunning 42% sales drop in China. The world’s largest car market, once a reliable growth engine for the German automaker, has become a liability amid rising protectionism, weak consumer confidence, and a fiercely competitive EV sector.

Blume hasn’t minced words about the road ahead. Porsche is expected to move away from its prior goal of 80% electric vehicle sales by 2030, and more investment will be reallocated to hybrid and combustion powertrains. It’s a dramatic pivot for a brand that only a year ago appeared all-in on electrification.
Porsche’s warning comes at a pivotal moment not just for the company, but for the industry at large. With global demand for EVs cooling and trade politics turning up the heat, even luxury stalwarts aren’t immune to the turbulence. Porsche’s leadership says further announcements about structural changes will follow later this year."
 
Too much fleecing for too long
Their prices are insane these days
Their prices have always been insane. Years ago a co-worker had a Porsche 928 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Porsche_928). The HVAC blower would run at top speed only. I knew the problem was the fan resistor. Went to the local Porsche dealer for a new part. $90!. We walked across the parking lot to the BMW parts location. Identical part was $30.
 
The biggest problem is China; Porsche's, and the world's, biggest market.
Porsche has had an engineering facility in Shanghai for over 20 years, focusing on technology and digital solutions, and they've recently opened an R&D satellite office there dedicated to the Chinese market. Their China dealership plans are changing...

Of course the US market has had issues with price increases.

I am confident CEO Blume will navigate his company through its biggest challenges in decades.
All automakers are facing challenges in today's market.
 
Last edited:
That's the usual talk before they start slashing the workforce. Somehow record profits from the years prior cannot sustain them through this short term pain. Next they will be begging for the taxpayer money.
The problem is, this is not short term pain. And it ain't just the mighty Porsche.
 
The problem is, this is not short term pain. And it ain't just the mighty Porsche.
They have had a facility in China for over 20 years, and dealing with them for even longer. So they couldn't think of a possibility of the Chinese markets going down at some point?
Now we have a market correction after record high profits in the past several years and they're acting like it's a surprise. Where have all the profits gone to?

It's always the same pattern, doesn't really matter the company or country. When the profits are record high, they all rake it all in, then they have few bad quarters and they act as if the sky was falling. Of course in both scenarios it's the regular employees that take the brunt of it all. In record profit time they don't get the raises they deserve and then a lot of them get axed the moment there is trouble on the horizon. Rinse and repeat.
 
They have had a facility in China for over 20 years, and dealing with them for even longer. So they couldn't think of a possibility of the Chinese markets going down at some point?
Now we have a market correction after record high profits in the past several years and they're acting like it's a surprise. Where have all the profits gone to?

It's always the same pattern, doesn't really matter the company or country. When the profits are record high, they all rake it all in, then they have few bad quarters and they act as if the sky was falling. Of course in both scenarios it's the regular employees that take the brunt of it all. In record profit time they don't get the raises they deserve and then a lot of them get axed the moment there is trouble on the horizon.
What you are saying is true, but perhaps not appropriate to the current car business. China is everyone's biggest market; the loss hurts everyone and forces CEOs to change course to adapt, or risk worse results.

If CEO Blume thought the problems were short term, then weathering the storm makes sense. But if the problems are deeper than that, tough choices are required.

Porsche is a high margin/low volume car company. If they believe the market for their current carsis declining over the longer term, and/or the cost to manufacture them (particularly labor in Porsche's case) is rising or too high to sustain, they have to adjust. CEO Blume is beholden to the shareholders, not the employees. When your biggest market is practically going away; that's a long term problem.

Every product, every company, has a life cycle. In business you grow or you go. Growth is painful; demand is not a straight line.

By the way, the Shanghai facility is an engineering center, taking advantage of the huge Chinese engineering talent.
 
Last edited:
Porsches have a reputation, like all the other pricey Euro cars, of being unreliable and requiring constant repairs and maintenance. You and I wouldn't accept that from a Toyota or a Ford. Maybe buyers are tiring of that.
 
Too much fleecing for too long
Their prices are insane these days
But they are still selling them, at least the 911's and they are excellent for what they are.

Ending the Boxster/Cayman line IC line appeared somewhat ill conceived at the time, although there were several reasons, but looks very bad now as does the heavy bet on EV's globally. While the 911 line is still selling well, at least today, I question the directional change to more hybrid drive and less manuals. The SUV/CUV market is one of commodities and Porsches offerings, while some are special, are just several of many available choices.

I'm a long time Porsche fan, obviously, but have noticed with some dismay that they seem to have moved their marketing strategy to one of a "lifestyle brand", with the fashion and eco aura, corresponding prices and unfortunately decreased focus on the core mission of building excellent driver's cars at reasonable price (for what they are; a Porsche will always be pricey) .
 
Last edited:
Porsches have a reputation, like all the other pricey Euro cars, of being unreliable and requiring constant repairs and maintenance. You and I wouldn't accept that from a Toyota or a Ford. Maybe buyers are tiring of that.
Amongst whom? Seriously.

I've been in the Porsche world for a very long time and while P'cars certainly have their faults, "being unreliable and requiring constant repairs...." is not one of them. Not many owners I know feel that way, I have been around a lot over the years.

People who complain about the problems with their six figure miles Boxster they bought from its fifth owner who maintained it with "just like OEM" Amazon/Ebay parts' opinions don't count. They aren't buying new.
 
Porsches have a reputation, like all the other pricey Euro cars, of being unreliable and requiring constant repairs and maintenance. You and I wouldn't accept that from a Toyota or a Ford. Maybe buyers are tiring of that.
Is that reputation totally deserved? Although I haven't owned a Porsche, I've done a fair amount of research, as I have considered a Panamera and a Cayenne in the past.

From what I have learned, I would agree that a Porsche can be expensive to own. Maintenance is very detailed and if done proper, includes very extensive preventative maintenance. Of course that is assuming the maintenance is being done at a Porsche dealership, or a shop specializing in Porsche. And parts are expensive.

But from what I have found, Porsches tend to be quite reliable. Toyota reliable? No, but likely better than Ford reliable. Especially if the Ford owner fixed things that failed, to keep the car pristine, instead of just living with problems. (Yea, I said it out loud.) Besides, the comparison is actually quite absurd. Except for the Ford GT, which was only offered for a very limited run, neither Ford or Toyota offer anything that would be considered a competitor to any Porsche offering. And while I haven't owned as many European luxury cars as many others here, I have had a few. And I would argue that most owners of these cars understand that a fine car takes more maintenance. You don't get all the premium features, functions, and luxury out of a car by staying with the basics.
 
The German carmakers all have a problem with high fixed costs, particularly labor costs. Add the costs to transition to EV, which may now be stranded, and and subpar results in China and it will be challenging.
 
Back
Top Bottom