OLD TRUCKS VS NEW TRUCKS

Joined
Nov 22, 2004
Messages
10,941
Location
Texas
Just an observation. My son has a 1985 C10 pickup. Pretty nice truck has factory AC, power windows/locks, Silverado trim level etc. Has the 350/TH400 combo and not a power house but gets the job done. Here is where I made a dramatic realization- went with him to get a round bale for my horses and first thing I notice is the truck rides decent (it is a 2WD) and the hood slants downwards making visability MUCH MUCH better then newer trucks with the huge hoods etc. I was like hey I love my RAM and Sierra Denali but this old '85 C10 does everything they do with better visability and almost as much comfort- just less bells, whistles and power. I could see everything on the road and parking was easy - guess that is why my RAM has front and rear park aids because you can't see anything!
 
Yeah and manufacturers took advantage of the federal mandate of BUCs to make rear visibility extra poor, esp in SUVs

My problem with your exact example is carburetion. Move a couple years to TBI and I'm in! And it's gotta be 4wd here in CO ;)
 
So I have owned a 71 K5, 85 square body, 1989 GMC 1 ton, 88 Chevy 3/4 ton, 97 Chevy 350 1500, 02 2500HD, 17 3500 HD and the current 24 2500HD. I'll be brief. Everything before 02 was eh. Your memories are only remembering the good stuff, Kind like when you retire from the Military. The 24 is amazing, brakes, power, comfort. No way would I hook up to The float or my travel trailer with the OBS stuff and before and pull in modern traffic. Crap brakes, intake leaks, spider injection. 3 and 4 speed transmissions, TBI. You fine folks can keep that old stuff.
 
Old trucks are simply more reliable.

Let me know when a 2024 Silverado or 2024 F150 makes it to 39 years on the original engine and transmission, accessories, etc.

New trucks only win on gas mileage and safety.
How bout we just talk about mileage. The GM gas 6.6 has been out since 2020 a bunch with 200,000 to 300,000 miles on them and tow 15,000 lbs. No Carbed or TBI truck with a 350 or 454 is doing that. Reliably or keeping up with modern traffic. My 89 GMC had a 454 replaced at 54,000 mile. It towed a whole 5500 lbs 5th wheel, second engine was better. Lets talk about how long none lock up turbo 400s and 350s live behind that weight. 700R4? Nope. I have had plenty of old trucks. When you are talking 3/4 ton and up I do not agree at all. Trucks are for work. New trucks do it better.
 
Last edited:
How bout we just talk about mileage. The GM gas 6.6 has been out since 2020 a bunch with 200,000 to 300,000 miles on them and tow 15,000 lbs. No Carbed or TBI truck with a 350 or 454 is doing that. Reliably or keeping up with modern traffic. My 89 GMC had a 454 replaced at 54,000 mile. It towed a whole 5500 lbs 5th wheel, second engine was better. Lets talk about how long none lock up turbo 400s and 350s live behind that weight. 700R4? Nope. I have had plenty of old trucks. When you are talking 3/4 ton and up I do not agree at all. Trucks are for work. New trucks do it better.
Did you really just say no 350 or 454 is going to make it 200,000 miles?

What planet have you been living on?.
 
Here is my current micro fleet of little old to nearly new. 2002 f350 w V10 and 4.33 rear, 2004 navigator with a 32v V8, 2015 f350 w 6.2l V8, and a 2019 f350 dually with a 6.7 diesel.

All these trucks perform well do cross country hauling with fully loaded trailers without fear.

The dually is a beast and has features beyond belief. But the sleeper of the four, the Navigator with the 32v V8. Earlier this week I did a trailer tow 1750 miles across numerous mountain rangers with a loaded 7500 lbs trailer, and the interior of the Navigator was loaded with tools.

The 2004 Navigator towed like a dream, the air suspension was wonderful, and the fuel mileage very impressive. But, no air suspension parts available for the Navigator, and many other parts are discontinued. Makes keep the Navigator on the road questionable.
PXL_20240823_020529221.webp
 
Did you really just say no 350 or 454 is going to make it 200,000 miles?

What planet have you been living on?.
They do, but not towing like new trucks. I had 3 of them.I put lots of miles on all of them. The TBI trucks were horrible. Intake leaks, TBI adapter leaks, a/c
Failures, crap brakes, the frames sucked. I can go on and on. Honestly I think the last 6.0/6l90E GM trucks were their best 3/4 ton and up gassers GM has made.
 
Last edited:
They do, but not towing like new trucks. I had 3 of them.I put lots of miles on all of them. The TBI trucks were horrible. Intake leaks, TBI adapter leaks, a/c
Failures, crap brakes, the frames sucked. I can go on and on.
Tell me how your 2024 holds up in 39 years. Btw those 6.6 gassers have been failing with under 10,000 miles, how are those transmissions holding up? not well.
 
Yeah and manufacturers took advantage of the federal mandate of BUCs to make rear visibility extra poor, esp in SUVs

My problem with your exact example is carburetion. Move a couple years to TBI and I'm in! And it's gotta be 4wd here in CO ;)
I agree! He has a friend with an 87 and the FI makes a difference. My son is just going to go the Holly fuel injection kit down the road. We are also 4WD only truck guys but this one came along in a unique way - we were restoring it for a girl who was going to give it to her Dad. We already did all the work mechanically and I mean everything was done. The next step was interior and paint but she got in a huge fight with her dad and she said hey sell it I am done. Mind you she already bought the truck and was paying us to restore it - she let us have it for $2500 so even as 2WD we bought it.
 
So I have owned a 71 K5, 85 square body, 1989 GMC 1 ton, 88 Chevy 3/4 ton, 97 Chevy 350 1500, 02 2500HD, 17 3500 HD and the current 24 2500HD. I'll be brief. Everything before 02 was eh. Your memories are only remembering the good stuff, Kind like when you retire from the Military. The 24 is amazing, brakes, power, comfort. No way would I hook up to The float or my travel trailer with the OBS stuff and before and pull in modern traffic. Crap brakes, intake leaks, spider injection. 3 and 4 speed transmissions, TBI. You fine folks can keep that old stuff.
You didn't say anything wrong for sure. I agree. My post was more nostalgic and how you can see better and the trucks were not so big as they are now.
 
Here is my current micro fleet of little old to nearly new. 2002 f350 w V10 and 4.33 rear, 2004 navigator with a 32v V8, 2015 f350 w 6.2l V8, and a 2019 f350 dually with a 6.7 diesel.

All these trucks perform well do cross country hauling with fully loaded trailers without fear.

The dually is a beast and has features beyond belief. But the sleeper of the four, the Navigator with the 32v V8. Earlier this week I did a trailer tow 1750 miles across numerous mountain rangers with a loaded 7500 lbs trailer, and the interior of the Navigator was loaded with tools.

The 2004 Navigator towed like a dream, the air suspension was wonderful, and the fuel mileage very impressive. But, no air suspension parts available for the Navigator, and many other parts are discontinued. Makes keep the Navigator on the road questionable.
View attachment 238014
I think that gen of Navigator was the best looking ever. The new ones are not near as classy.
 
Tell me how your 2024 holds up in 39 years. Btw those 6.6 gassers have been failing with under 10,000 miles, how are those transmissions holding up? not well.
They also make and sell a lot more trucks now then they did in the 80s and 90s so it Is logical to see some failures because they make so many. The 10 speed is pretty good and please show me all the 6.6 failures. I'm on 3 large sites and it is few and far between. If you think that never happened to a 350 or 454 we are certainly not on the same planet, you only have to talk to the RV guys and farmers.
 
How bout we just talk about mileage. The GM gas 6.6 has been out since 2020 a bunch with 200,000 to 300,000 miles on them and tow 15,000 lbs. No Carbed or TBI truck with a 350 or 454 is doing that. Reliably or keeping up with modern traffic. My 89 GMC had a 454 replaced at 54,000 mile. It towed a whole 5500 lbs 5th wheel, second engine was better. Lets talk about how long none lock up turbo 400s and 350s live behind that weight. 700R4? Nope. I have had plenty of old trucks. When you are talking 3/4 ton and up I do not agree at all. Trucks are for work. New trucks do it better.
Who is towing 8 tons with a half ton. Apples to oranges.

Come park your 3/4 ton in a downtown parking ramp and get back to me on how awesome they are.

I personally believe anything over GVWR of about 5 tons should be a commercial license. I see 5th wheels upside down in the ditch on a regular basis on the interstates here, or driving their 5th wheel around like its some sort of sports car. And yes, I have driven much larger myself, including class A. Grew up around such things and have driven almost everything at one point or another.
 
They do, but not towing like new trucks. I had 3 of them.I put lots of miles on all of them. The TBI trucks were horrible. Intake leaks, TBI adapter leaks, a/c
Failures, crap brakes, the frames sucked. I can go on and on. Honestly I think the last 6.0/6l90E GM trucks were their best 3/4 ton and up gassers GM has made.
I have a few questions here!

1) Were you using Synthetic Trans Fluid?
2) Did you have a Deeper Trans Pan with more capacity?
3) Were you running an External Trans Cooler, like a Derale Trans Cooler that has the Stacked Plate setup?
 
Back
Top