Oil filter crush temperature, with no bypass.

A spin-on oil filter is a component that can contain BPV's, filter media, media cage, anti-drainback valves, a ring gasket, and spring, and an outer shell of thin steel to hold the internal components, depending on the design.

What you are describing is an internal "overpressure" condition which 'collapsed' the media and or media cage, possibly due to some high pressure anomaly.

When a person speaks of a filter collapsing, one usually means the totality of the filter, that is, the thin outer shell of steel has collapsed in toward the components as if it had been run over.


Had people been more specific in their language, I doubt this thread would have come this far.


It was a long filter like this rather than a spin on. The bypass valve was built into the filter housing. Not so obvious but this is the actual crushed filter before the media and end caps were stripped off.

Crushed Filter1.webp
 
It was a long filter like this rather than a spin on. The bypass valve was built into the filter housing. Not so obvious but this is the actual crushed filter before the media and end caps were stripped off.

View attachment 236484
Good illustration. At one trucking company, I have seen the media "cage" end caps completely separated from the media cage but the cage was even more distorted.
 
Yep. All the sbc’s and bbc’s I’ve built or was involved with had the HV pumps with the HP spring and pinned drives.
That’s why I don’t recommend plugging the oil filter mount bypass.
More than a few times Chevy oil filters have blown out at the drag strip often around the 60 foot mark.
A #9100 Duramax filter, say what you want, adds another layer of burst protection.
Jet boat owners with BBCs are the most notorious for this. They will start a cold engine, 30 seconds later pin it and roost people on the dock, 15 seconds later the stock harmonic balancer ring goes through the hull followed by the crankshaft.
Yeah I have been using the 9100 size oil filter on old gm products forever. With paper filter it was like a dollar more to get almost double the oil filter.
 
Cool! How did that one happen?


Oil at -5 deg C and inadvertent excessive revs after starting. The oil pump on my old BMW motorcycles shifts 16 liters per minute at even moderate revs. There is a filter bypass valve but it's quite small and a relief valve set at 74 PSI but a system pressure in excess of 100 PSI is normal with cold oil even at much higher ambient temperatures.
 
Oil at -5 deg C and inadvertent excessive revs after starting. The oil pump on my old BMW motorcycles shifts 16 liters per minute at even moderate revs. There is a filter bypass valve but it's quite small and a relief valve set at 74 PSI but a system pressure in excess of 100 PSI is normal with cold oil even at much higher ambient temperatures.
Oh wow only -35c that's not even cold.
16L per minute seems quite excessive for a bike engine.
 
16L per minute seems quite excessive for a bike engine.

It is high but perhaps it helps explain why the bottom end of these engines will do 200,000 miles with ease which is not usual for a motorcycle. When raced the oil pump consumes so much power at high revs it has to be modified to pump less oil.
 
Oil at -5 deg C and inadvertent excessive revs after starting. The oil pump on my old BMW motorcycles shifts 16 liters per minute at even moderate revs. There is a filter bypass valve but it's quite small and a relief valve set at 74 PSI but a system pressure in excess of 100 PSI is normal with cold oil even at much higher ambient temperatures.
The flow rate is about 300mL/s or about 10 ounces/s so that doesn't seem overly excessive for a performance oil pump.
 
What you are describing is an internal "overpressure" condition which 'collapsed' the media and or media cage, possibly due to some high pressure anomaly.
More accurately, it's an over delta-pressure across the media and center tube, not an actual internal over pressure inside the filter for the outside can to handle. The pressure on the dirty side of the filter could be 100 PSI (not over pressure for the can) and only have 15 PSI of dP across the media/center tube. Or the pressure in a different operating scenario on the dirty side could be 150 PSI (not over pressure for the can) with the dP across the media/center tube well over 15 PSI and enough to crush ("implode") the center tube - especially if there is not a filter bypass in the filter or system.
 
Last edited:
More accurately, it's an over delta-pressure across the media and center tube, not an actual internal over pressure inside the filter for the outside can to handle. The pressure on the dirty side of the filter could be 100 PSI (not over pressure for the can) and only have 15 PSI of dP across the media/center tube. Or the pressure in a different operating scenario on the dirty side could be 150 PSI (not over pressure for the can) with the dP across the media/center tube well over 15 PSI and enough to crush ("implode") the center tube - especially if there is not filter bypass in the filter or system.
Yes, internally it is the Delta pressure that crushes the cage.

The point is, it was a differential pressure that crushes or distorts.
 
Fresh oil, didn't catch the weight they were using. Filter was a big old 51515 or 91000 size, much bigger than what most engines run. Developed some psid even at room temperature. I bet an engine would develope a lot more psid below freezing with a partially dirty filter.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Fresh oil, didn't catch the weight they were using. Filter was a big old 51515 or 91000 size, much bigger than what most engines run. Developed some psid even at room temperature. I bet an engine would develope a lot more psid below freezing with a partially dirty filter.
There's a whole thread on that video in the Oil Filter forum.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
There's a whole thread on that video in the Oil Filter forum.

Any excuse to pull a LS jr video.
Someone should leave a comment recommend he make nursery safe videos.
 
Back
Top Bottom