Here's a chart of the properties of various rubber compounds. You'll see that nitrile, especially HNBR, is superior in every way to silicone in both the physical and chemical properties that are important to an oil filter base gasket. Oh, yea, the HNBR is also more expensive than silicone.
An argument can be made that the wider temperature range of silicone would be better for the ADBV. On the other hand, we've seen silicon ADBVs, with its poor physical properties, damaged by the inlet holes.
https://mykin.com/rubber-properties
Ed
I see lots of numbers on that rubber chart but no key as to what those numbers mean.