My Journey Begins, Cancer and Medicare, Maybe this will help some others one day

I wish you the best! My dad was diagnosed with prostate cancer last year at 73. He chose surgery, but there were complications and the surgeon stopped the surgery before he got very far. So, Dad had radiation treatments, and so far is doing well. His Dr warned him about probable nasty side effects during the treatment, but the worst thing he experienced was extreme fatigue.

Coincidentally, I was diagnosed with kidney cancer in May, and had a nephrectomy in August, so Dad and I were being treated for cancer at the same time. I just had my first CT scan, and everything looked good. I will have scans every 6 months.
Glad your dad is doing well. I am curious, did they stop the surgery because they ran into scar tissue?
I ask because I was told, there was a 20% chance, should I choose removal that once I was opened up they may have to stop and close because of scar tissue.
Yes, radiation is going to make me tired along with the drug I am taking is going to do a number on me for 6 months. I think the drug is going to be worse than the radiation, radiation 5 weeks, drug 6 months. Im all for it though, to beat this thing and glad I am getting the best that the current PROVEN technologies can offer me. It's a crappy cancer to have. No right or wrong way to treat it depending on each individual person and their doctors.

My personal thoughts are radiation in the 1990s was scary stuff only based on my own reading of not being well focused as today.
2000s it start to come under refinement, currently 2020's some see it better than prostate surgery due to its precision MRI/CT technology the impact on surrounding tissue is much less. BUT not gone. Of course, I was influenced by my doctors, actually a team, who each believed in what they do, surgeons and radiologists in MY PARTICULAR situation, none are exactly the same between different people. I have to admit that I am REALLY excited to get started.

Continued good wishes for him!

Im at a loss for words regarding your cancer, except I wish you well and glad to hear everything is coming up good on the scan and future scans.

I have to admit I am REALLY excited to get started, the meds came in on Jan 15th and started taking them. On Jan 23rd I have almost a full day, 1st meeting with a Medical Oncologist just for the sake of reviewing the medication I already started, 2nd meeting is my radiation oncologist (and maybe setting a schedule), 3rd will be mapping the area that radiation will be applied, 4th will be CT/MRI scan.
Wife coming with me, my day will start there at 8AM and hope to be done at 1Pm.
 
Last edited:
Glad your dad is doing well. I am curious, did they stop the surgery because they ran into scar tissue?
I wasn't there the day of the surgery, so I'm going off of what my mom told me. I know there was mention of more bleeding than the Dr expected, and also they had trouble keeping his blood pressure stable while under anesthesia. The third factor she said was something about the fat tissue being difficult to cut through, but now that I've read your comment, I'm wondering if she misunderstood, and it was actually scar tissue.

Thanks for your kind words and well wishes!
 
Well holy cow alarmguy…

Take care of yourself… One day at a time.

If you need anything you can send me a pm.

Several great posts on here by you. . No surprise there. You have a habit of doing that.
Thank you for your good wishes.
Im excited for Jan 23rd and hoping the weather doesnt cause them to cancel my appointments for the day. MRI Tech just called me to confirm, so far he has not heard any talk for cancelling appts.
It doesnt seem (at the moment) much snowfall but any amount may not be good. I dont know if they have salt trucks here. I only moved to this area in 2023. They didnt have them at our last home in SC.
The concern might be freezing rain and the trip is a one hour trip. We will see, so far it's a go and the good news is I am taking the drug which I have to take for weeks before radiation anyway. SO I am already being treated by the drug.
 
(long read but those interested might find it useful)
Well, after beating the most serious part of a family history of diabetes and heart disease (I still have some arterial disease, genetic) but no intervention of even drugs are needed unlike all the males in my family which were a train wreck and had heart by-passes 20 years before my current age. Being the youngest I decided to not let that happen to me and I pretty much beat it, even though I have High LipoProtein A which nothing can be done about. I made sure to eat healthy. I also avoided diabetes (so far)

So, what do you know? since 2017 I have had very high PSA levels it started at a 4.7 and ended 7 years later at higher and way higher than 10___. Multiple MRI's and 4 Biopsies the first 3 over the years turned up nothing the last one in Sept 2024 turned up cancer.
Out of 12 samples taken only 2 came back, that was good and most likely because I was very aggressive on insisting on Biopies. One core showed a 3/3 which really doesnt call for action at that point. The other was a 3/4 which would be considered intermediate risk. This to me was VERY early stage and I wanted it gone.

So my regular urologist calls me up to see what I want to do. Watchful waiting, Radiation or Surgery. He clearly thought Surgery was not at all called for (but read on) I couldnt make up my mind, so there was a 4th option. A referral to Duke University Cancer Clinic almost one of the top 10 in the USA. We (my wife and I) got an appointment a few days before Thanksgiving 2024 to meet with 3 specialists who spent hours with us, just for us, just to review my case and get the options, individually one on one. One Oncology Radiologist, One Surgeon and One Medical Oncologist
My wife and I made the 3 hour trip and stayed in a hotel for the meeting the next day. FREAKING wonderful experience. The entire 5th floor devoted specifically to prostate and other cancers involving that area and we were there. Just for me.

Throughout ALL of this my Medicare ADVANTAGE plan paid for everything, not one hiccup not one objection, no stipulations.

Sadly all 3 specialists were very concerned. It caught my wife and I off guard. Here I was so happy that I found out about this cancer so quickly and being so proactive, almost insisting my Dr do a biopsy. But they explained to me, even though my PSA was down to 11.5 it had to be doubled to a PSA of 23 because of a drug I was on. I found out that all three doctors were to label me "High Risk" and bumped me up from a 7 to more like 8 to 10 (10 being the worst) with favorable outcome.
Also I found out if I wanted surgery it might not be successful do to heavy scarring from an appendectomy I had in the 4th grade that couldnt be closed up at the time, I was septic and almost died. So the surgeon said if I want surgery, robotics is out and he will do it by incision but a 20% chance I will wake up only to find out he cut me open and could not proceed. I was almost relieved in the sense that radiation and drug therapy was making more sense.

Based on the 3 doctors, they ordered a PSMA PET SCAN the latest state of the art scan to see if prostate cancer spread in my body. They were very concerned on how my PSA can be 23 and only 2 cores showing cancer, they felt something great must be going on. However the earliest available appt was Jan 2nd so they offered if I could get one sooner near where I live by all means do it. I told them I want to be treated there, they offered there are many doctors good near me and mentioned one name in particular of a Radio Oncologist that they love and wanted him up at Duke that is within 1 hour from me. I arraigned though the new doctor closer to me AND instant response of the doctors at Duke to get a PSMA SCAN ordered closer to me on Dec 20th and follow up with the new doctor near me on Dec 30th. So thanks to Duke within 2 hours the order for a PSMA PET SCAN arrived at a place closer to me. I was so impressed and also impressed with the staff at what will become my new doctor. All this time, unknown to me and handled by their offices approval was needed by my Advantage Plan, I only found out because I got a letter in the mail it was approved. Once again, no hiccups at all from my plan. The retail cost of this scan was $19,000 and it was determined as far as the scan can tell, the cancer has not spread to any other part of my body.

SO that ends my journey with my medicare advantage plan 2024/ NOT ONE QUESTION, NOT ONE HOLD UP. EVERYTHING PAID FOR.
With that said the current Advantage Plan wasnt being offered in the New Year 2025 and I could care less, I just pick a new one on line on the government website and as soon as you click, you are covered for 2025.

HOWEVER since the provider had decided (Aetna) not to offer this plan for 2025 I also had the right to go into standard Medigap Plan with NO underwriting and guaranteed acceptance. SO here I am with cancer and after thinking about it for a month or so ( I knew way ahead of time) I decided for 2025 to go into private Medigap Plan N which includes Government A and B plus private plan D for drugs. The cost is only $135 extra a month and of that, they will pay a gym cost of up to $110 a month! Net would be $25 including the drug plan so why not? Here I was about to battle cancer and there would not be much to think about.

Why did I decide to go to Medigap from an Advantage plans I so loved for 3 years? Simple, chances are it will cost me less for the year and to be honest, since I am new to the area I wouldnt have to worry about who is in network. I will say, after 2025 I plan but on going back to Advantage C if this all resolves itself. But I honestly do not know right now, though as of right now my Drs are in the Advantage Plan I would choose if I did there seems to be a little turmoil from year to year. The reason for this post is I read stories about Medicare and it's a wonderful system if you take advantage of it and use it, educate yourself right on the https://www.medicare.gov/ website, you can read of days and study.

So the decision was made. Fantastic doctor here on the coast who my wife and I liked very much and they like him up at Duke that they wanted him to move up there, he didnt want too.
I am to undergo radiation and drug therapy. This doctor changed my threat designation a little bit. But he explained it means the same. From high risk favorable outcome to intermediate risk unfavorable outcome.

Yesterday, Wed, the drug was delivered to my house. I am to take one pill a day for 6 months. The drug cost is up to $3000 a month x 6 months roughly $18,000 but can be as little as $14,000 my cost is $2000 thanks to the new medicare drug out of pocket limit for 2025 or it would have been $8,000. My life as I know it will change for the next 6 months and I am not looking forward to it because of the drug but I want to live and make sure this thing is knocked out. The side effects are not going to be pleasant. However they are being aggressive in the sense they use this for high risk cases and in cases where it has spread.

Next week I am going to spend over another half day, meeting with two specialists (one of which is my new doctor) arranging and going over what will be my radiation schedule coming up which will be 5 days a week for 5 weeks as well as MRI and CT scan. This past Monday my regular urologist implanted 3 gold markers inside my body that the computer will use as markers in order to deliver the radiation to the proper area and avoid other areas as much as possible. My doctor tells me the survival rate is 90% for 15 years.

Prostate cancer sucks. The possible side effects of surgery or radiation are different but both can suck. Though immediate side effects for me with radiation will be almost none, 3 years down the road it POSSIBLY can rear its ugly head and even expose you in the future to cancers because of the radiation itself. My hope is, as time goes on medicine advances. One reason how far we have come was surgery was always preferred as late is 2006 now radiation is much more focused and that trend is almost reversed DEPENDING ON YOUR CASE>

SO FOR ALL OF YOU, MAKE SURE YOU ARE GETTING REGULAR CHECK UPS, DONT BE AFRAID OF YOUR DOCTOR, SURE EDUCATE YOURSELF, READ UP BUT ONLY SO YOU CAN TALK TO YOUR DOCTOR AND UNDERSTAND THE CONVERSATION. DO NOT RELY ON INTERNET FORUMS AND WHAT OTHER PEOPLE SAY. YOUR DOCTOR IS THE KEY. MY POST IS ABOUT BEING PRO ACTIVE IN DOING SO, DONT BE AFRAID OF TESTS, IF YOUR DOCTOR GIVES YOU THAT OPTION, TAKE IT, DONT PUT IT OFF.
From the sound of my cancer (they are all different in aggressiveness) I am so glad I was almost insistent on my 4th biopsy when my doctor gave me the choice to wait another six months or do it now.

As far as Medicare Advantage C plans and Medigap Plans plus D plan it comes down to cost and what you want and what you are willing to pay and possibly give up depending on the area you live. I loved my Advantage C plans but given the chance to go back (at least for now) Medicare A, B and private Medigap N plus private Plan D makes everything thoughtless for the extra monthly premium.

Medigap costs are pretty much fixed where the Advantage C plan can get pricey if your copays add up to many thousands and you have to stay in network. So right now, yeah, I am happy to be in Medigap the purpose of my post is to highlight my personal experience. Im sure the end result would be the same with my Advantage Plan. However should your Advantage C plan not be offered the following year, the system once again worked perfect. In the mist of a cancer diagnosis I got an unconditional acceptance into Medigap because my plan wasnt being offered and that gave me the option of choosing anything I wanted. If my plan was still offered I would think NO WAY would I have been accepted into Medigap and that is something each individual needs to know. Once you are in Advantage c you can only get out in the 1st year for guaranteed acceptance. UNLESS your Advantage C plan is no longer offered.
The system works and works very well, I am thrilled that I live in the USA and can get this latest technology, latest drug therapy that even my regular urologist never prescribed before. People trash our health care system, well, you will be thankful in cases like mine.
I was able to consult with a total of 5 specialists plus my regular urologist (who is specialist in his own right) and my cost was pennies. Making educated decisions is up to you, get opinions.
Praying for you man, f*c# cancer. You seem well versed, and an active participant, in your plan of care. Those are important aspects of this process and being proactive, which you most certainly are, often aids in positive outcomes. My daughter had cancer at 17 months (she’s now almost 5). I can relate to the roller coaster ride from hell. Fight the good fight and pray.
 
Praying for you man, f*c# cancer. You seem well versed, and an active participant, in your plan of care. Those are important aspects of this process and being proactive, which you most certainly are, often aids in positive outcomes. My daughter had cancer at 17 months (she’s now almost 5). I can relate to the roller coaster ride from hell. Fight the good fight and pray.
How is your daughter doing?
Around a decade or two back my nephew, who is now married, and has children was a relatively young age I believe still in high school when he somehow developed Hodgkin’s lymphoma. I can certainly understand how affected one might be even more so when a young person is stricken with cancer.

I hope your daughter is doing well, that must be really rough. My nephew beat it and it’s been a long time now and still no return of the cancer.
I donated to St Jude’s Children's Hospital this year, I have in the past but I am going to make a habit of it every year at Christmas time.

For those that don’t know Saint Jude’s is a children’s cancer research hospital and they do not charge for treating children, maybe everyone, but at the very least for those that cannot pay.
 
How is your daughter doing?
Around a decade or two back my nephew, who is now married, and has children was a relatively young age I believe still in high school when he somehow developed Hodgkin’s lymphoma. I can certainly understand how affected one might be even more so when a young person is stricken with cancer.

I hope your daughter is doing well, that must be really rough. My nephew beat it and it’s been a long time now and still no return of the cancer.
I donated to St Jude’s Children's Hospital this year, I have in the past but I am going to make a habit of it every year at Christmas time.

For those that don’t know Saint Jude’s is a children’s cancer research hospital and they do not charge for treating children, maybe everyone, but at the very least for those that cannot pay.
Thank you very much for the kind words. Yes, a cancer diagnosis affects everyone in the “patients” life. It’s an awful disease that I am very glad to hear your nephew overcame. I hope, and pray, you overcome this as well. It’s great to know that your nephew is thriving as an adult, and parent, now. His kids may not be of age to realize how lucky they are to have “dad” in their life, but will one day cherish that. Cancer most definitely affects one’s outlook on life; both those diagnosed and their family/friends as well. Donating to St. Jude’s is fantastic and commendable. There are kids much less fortunate, in terms of health insurance and the financial means to obtain superior levels of care, that need this assistance. Thank you for your contribution. I didn’t elaborate regarding my daughter as I didn’t want to detract from your post; however, I did want to express my concern, offer my prayers, and note my ability to relate to your situation. Again, thank you for asking about her; she is doing well. She was diagnosed with stage E Retinoblastoma (the most advanced stage) at 17 months. My wife and I are both RN’s and thought we caught this early (thought she had a lazy eye initially and sought treatment for it). She had to have an enucleation (her right eye was removed) due to the severity of the cancer. Fortunately, she did not require chemo or radiation. She has undergone many exams under anesthesia and continues to be monitored to this day; now in the office since she is older. My wife and I are truly appreciative of the care that she receives at the Cleveland Clinic. But again, this isn’t about our journey this is about yours. And I genuinely hope that you persevere and beat this. Remain optimistic, pray often, and know that those around you are with you along the way.
 
Last edited:
@6.7 CTD
Thank you again for your good wishes. I still felt. I need to reply one last time and wish the best for you. Yes, a cancer diagnosis certainly changes your outlook on life.
Another reason that I had to respond is the Cleveland clinic. I know it well, but only from its publications, which I subscribed to typically that has to do with men’s health and cardiac health every month. I get one of those publications delivered to my home and ironically, one on the prostate
In addition, I got lucky enough here on the coast where I have a cardiologist who interned there. I don’t have any debilitating heart disease, but I do have some inherited yet. I stay proactive on that as well and my EF score is still at a perfect 60.

OK, sorry I’m rambling on, best wishes to you and God bless your daughter. It looks like maybe you caught this and she’s lucky to have the both of you for parents.
 
Thank you for your good wishes.
Im excited for Jan 23rd and hoping the weather doesnt cause them to cancel my appointments for the day. MRI Tech just called me to confirm, so far he has not heard any talk for cancelling appts.
...
@bbhero
Well scratch that. :(
We got 4 inches (possibly 5 in some areas (snow) by Wed morning, cold temperatures too. Didnt get above 32 on Wed and well I got a call Wed during the day 3 of the 4 appts were canceled for today Thursday. Medical oncologist, Radiation oncologist and the radiation simulation (they put you on the table to configure the radiation machine for the future treatments)

Only appt left today is an MRI at noon. Medical oncologist is rescheduled for Friday afternoon. Waiting on the radiation sim and radiation oncologist to reschedule.

Sun was strong Wed but still cold, 7AM today Thursday it is 17 degrees here at the coast of NC. There really are no or very little trucks to treat the roads and nothing to clear parking lots except the sunlight. This weather is kind of extreme, relentless cold for the coast here.
Oh well...

Good news is, it's been a week now of taking the drug Orgovyx so nothing is being held up as the drug needs to be taken for a period of time before the radiation. I just hate when appointments have to be changed around for fear someone might mis a step because of it. *LOL* Not only that but this is almost an hour drive from me and originally it was wrapped up nice and tidy for a full morning and early afternoon event all on one day. Now it will be scattered all over... oh well.

(update, last call just came in, everything canceled for today)
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately, Plan N is not an option with Guarantee Issue rights, it never has been. Someone or some people made mistakes along the way getting you enrolled in your supplement plan.
Because of MACRA if your Medicare coverage began before 2020 the plan F is only guarantee option and if your Medicare began in 2020 or after, plan G is the only guarantee option.
To obtain plan N it would need to be underwritten and with a recent cancer diagnosis it would be declined.
At the end of 2024, there were a lot of Advantage members that had this specific loss of coverage occur in many states and with a hand full of Insurance companies too.
Because of this, many insurance companies got backed up with an abnormal amount of guarantee issue applications. When this happens during the annual enrollment period some insurance companies will just auto approve applications without an underwriter overseeing anything. This is most likely why your plan N was approved.
I hope the insurance company does not find out during the two year incontestability period. They do have the right to rescind the policy, refund your premiums and deny any claim that has been paid.
Not trying to rain on your parade, just letting you know in case you start receiving mail from your insurance company in regards to this.
Good luck.
 
Unfortunately, Plan N is not an option with Guarantee Issue rights, it never has been. Someone or some people made mistakes along the way getting you enrolled in your supplement plan.
Because of MACRA if your Medicare coverage began before 2020 the plan F is only guarantee option and if your Medicare began in 2020 or after, plan G is the only guarantee option.
To obtain plan N it would need to be underwritten and with a recent cancer diagnosis it would be declined.
At the end of 2024, there were a lot of Advantage members that had this specific loss of coverage occur in many states and with a hand full of Insurance companies too.
Because of this, many insurance companies got backed up with an abnormal amount of guarantee issue applications. When this happens during the annual enrollment period some insurance companies will just auto approve applications without an underwriter overseeing anything. This is most likely why your plan N was approved.
I hope the insurance company does not find out during the two year incontestability period. They do have the right to rescind the policy, refund your premiums and deny any claim that has been paid.
Not trying to rain on your parade, just letting you know in case you start receiving mail from your insurance company in regards to this.
Good luck.
I was under the impression if your Medicare Advantage plan was terminated for your area, a person has the right to choose any plan regardless of preexisting conditions
 
Unfortunately, Plan N is not an option with Guarantee Issue rights, it never has been. Someone or some people made mistakes along the way getting you enrolled in your supplement plan.
Because of MACRA if your Medicare coverage began before 2020 the plan F is only guarantee option and if your Medicare began in 2020 or after, plan G is the only guarantee option.
To obtain plan N it would need to be underwritten and with a recent cancer diagnosis it would be declined.
At the end of 2024, there were a lot of Advantage members that had this specific loss of coverage occur in many states and with a hand full of Insurance companies too.
Because of this, many insurance companies got backed up with an abnormal amount of guarantee issue applications. When this happens during the annual enrollment period some insurance companies will just auto approve applications without an underwriter overseeing anything. This is most likely why your plan N was approved.
I hope the insurance company does not find out during the two year incontestability period. They do have the right to rescind the policy, refund your premiums and deny any claim that has been paid.
Not trying to rain on your parade, just letting you know in case you start receiving mail from your insurance company in regards to this.
Good luck.
Thank you, I need to look into this obviously I found what you are talking about.
This would be the question, and I will try to get in touch with an agent today. Since not too much has taken place this month but it’s about to next week and I might have to put it off.

My guaranteed issue right last until the end of February 2025
Will an agent be able to switch me into a plan G and will that plan G be effective starting January 1, 2025

I’m also questioning in regard to your statement regarding that two year. That protects policyholder and insurers.
I’m not quite sure that would pertain to this as it does not involve fraud.

With that said this information is helpful and I am going to look into it for sure. I do have a letter of acceptance stating continuation of coverage is the reason I have been accepted.
I seriously doubt an insurance company would be allowed to give somebody healthcare coverage, find out you were sick and then tell you that you can’t have the coverage once they find out that you are sick when they never asked any questions or looked into your claims history.

I appreciate the post because I have no problem going into plan G and at this point based on what you wrote, I would prefer too however I really need to speak to a very knowledgeable agent and fast. 🫤

More or less my thinking is they accepted me without underwriting. Also, when filling out the form I typed in Aetna Medicare advantage plan is not being offered for renewal 2025. Other than that, there were no health questions at all.

Thanks again for your post. I am definitely taking this serious because that’s who I am and we’ll seek to get it clarified because as it stands, I have to the end of February to go into a guaranteed acceptance plan.

Ps.
Come to think of it, guaranteed acceptance means just that. The company cant deny you unless it’s those two plans mentioned.
One of those is G, which is a great plan and about the same cost. So anyone with guaranteed acceptance clause has to be accepted into G, but that does not bar the company from excepting you into other plans.
If you’re accepted into another plan, to me it would make sense you have to be covered in that plan, it would be their fault for accepting somebody that they did not want to. Even more so, not looking into your history or asking any questions.
Meaning I applied for plan N and I was accepted because they accepted me.

I do appreciate this and it should be a warning for others to be careful because if I had to do it all over, I would’ve simply chose G, but I seriously doubt they could take away my plan N because they gave it to me to begin with.

You certainly made a great post and will be helpful to others in the future. Thank you.
I’ll look into it, but my key contention will be. I was already accepted and there was no fraud on my part involved. All I did was apply for a plan N
Letter of acceptance came in with the wording, something like “continuation of coverage”
@Pablo
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately, Plan N is not an option with Guarantee Issue rights, it never has been. Someone or some people made mistakes along the way getting you enrolled in your supplement plan.
Because of MACRA if your Medicare coverage began before 2020 the plan F is only guarantee option and if your Medicare began in 2020 or after, plan G is the only guarantee option.
To obtain plan N it would need to be underwritten and with a recent cancer diagnosis it would be declined.
At the end of 2024, there were a lot of Advantage members that had this specific loss of coverage occur in many states and with a hand full of Insurance companies too.
Because of this, many insurance companies got backed up with an abnormal amount of guarantee issue applications. When this happens during the annual enrollment period some insurance companies will just auto approve applications without an underwriter overseeing anything. This is most likely why your plan N was approved.
I hope the insurance company does not find out during the two year incontestability period. They do have the right to rescind the policy, refund your premiums and deny any claim that has been paid.
Not trying to rain on your parade, just letting you know in case you start receiving mail from your insurance company in regards to this.
Good luck.
Medicare Advantage plans are heavily advertised on early afternoon shows like Hot Bench, Steve Wilkos, Maury Povich, Karamo... should tell one all they need to know. People fall for the less important benefits they throw in...gym memberships, grocery allowances, Uber/Lyft reimbursement to appointments, OTC medicines, minimal dental and vision coverages, basically fluff.
When it comes to the serious claims...good luck.
I'm glad I squeaked under the wire for Plan F.
Plan G is your next best option.
 
Medicare Advantage plans are heavily advertised on early afternoon shows like Hot Bench, Steve Wilkos, Maury Povich, Karamo... should tell one all they need to know. People fall for the less important benefits they throw in...gym memberships, grocery allowances, Uber/Lyft reimbursement to appointments, OTC medicines, minimal dental and vision coverages, basically fluff.
When it comes to the serious claims...good luck.
I'm glad I squeaked under the wire for Plan F.
Plan G is your next best option.

And here we go

This thread is not about MA.

Why bring it up!?
 
Back
Top Bottom