In terms of chasing optimal, this certainly seems accurate in terms of lining up goals to usage contexts.
I recall even Amsoil’s Signature Series used to be primarily a high Calcium dosed extended drain oil when they first came out with that line. It has long since been tweaked for more magnesium/lowered calcium in the SS lineup; although I’m not sure if it’s considered mid-SAPS or full?
Also, for clarity you aren’t necessarily saying deposits will occur using Supercar, but might or possibly could if driven at lower temps; so the approach is avoiding the scenario all together? Because, to me, I’d be surprised if deposits were an issue with the kind of ingredients HPL uses vs say an OTS synthetic full SAPS.
Thanks
Mid vs full SAPS doesn't really have to do with Ca vs Mg because both sulfonates are metallic and will form ash when burned. This is the "sulphated ash" that is the SA part of SAPS. SAPS is more about the total amount of additive and detergency, not the constituent components of it. Note, the many newer ashless detergents and dispersant can provide very robust detergency while still being "low SAPS" because they make no ash when burned. Ash is essentially a metallic phenomenon, so ashless means basically "non metallic."
"Full SAPS" basically is a term of art that I take to mean allowing SA levels over 1%. This is essentially the SA limit of API CJ-4 and later in diesel specs.
Amsoil's shift to Mg-base is what everyone else mostly did also because of the LSPI requirements for SN+ and later, and the learning that Ca is an LSPI aggravator.
I'm not saying deposits will occur using Supercar, I'm just saying it might not be the best tool for EVERY job. It's IMO perhaps the best tool for particular kinds of jobs, those that tend to create higher temps. It's closer to racing oil and high SAPS Euro oils-- designed for elevated temperatures and particular kinds of deposit prevention (i.e. excellent against hard carbon and varnish).
But for colder, wetter kinds of deposits, the PCMO Mg-based add pack is likely more effective. Keep in mind, HPLs additives are VERY robust, and even the PCMO series is still going to have 1200ppm or so of Ca. But it's going to have Mg:Ca in about a 2:1, which is a known sweet spot for balancing the high temp, broad spectrum Ca with lower-temp, soot-and-sludge focused Mg.
In other words, even the PCMO has way more calcium than a lot of other SP-based oils. Likewise, the Supercar has a lot more Mg than other high-Ca oils.
HPL oils, in either formulation, are superbly balanced and effective in detergency. It's just that supercar and D1G2 based add packs have slightly different areas of emphasis.
As reference values, the PCMOs will typically have 2200ppm of Mg and 1200 or so of Ca. Supercar has more like 1000ppm of Mg and 2800 of Ca.
Contrast that with API SN 0w-40FS with 3400ppm Ca and effectively NO Mg. Or with SP-vintage Euro FS with 1400Ca and 1100 mg.|
The HPL PCMO has almost as much Ca as the Euro-FS "full SAPS" which is leaning on Ca primarily and has less than half as much Mg.
So whether you get SuperCar or PCMO, you are getting a highly enriched, extremely robust detergency package that crushes even other "full SAPS" oils and even some 50 grade oils (like Mobil 1 Supercar 5w-50).
Combining these packages with the super effective aminic antioxidants and oxidation resistant base oil blends (AN+ PAO or AN+GTL) and you have an oil that not only oxidizes very little but immediately addresses that tiny bit of oxidation with a very stout detergent package designed to arrest deposits in their infancy.