Got pulled over for Speeding

That's admission of guilt. Your training makes you trick people into admitting guilt, perhaps you realize it or not, doesn't matter. Your proposed response is admission of guilt.
That is not an admission of guilt, it is an acknowledgement of the officer’s statement rather than calling them a liar.

I sensed animosity for law enforcement in your first comment, and more so in this response.
 
Last edited:
I don't get many tickets, but I got a few...

When I get pulled over, I roll my window down, rest my left arm on the door, and dangle my right hand over the top of the steering wheel. If its at night, I turn on the interior lights. I don't kiss up to the cop, but I am courteous and cooperative. I announce every move like the OP did. I even had one cop thank me for being so purposely visible with my hands at night. I told him I did it for his comfort and my safety.
 
Were there any other vehicles traveling in that same area, that might of caused him to mistakenly pull you over?
Was his training up to date on whatever method of speed detection he was using?
Was his equipment calibrated and certified, in accordance with his department policies?
Were there any other factors, besides your alleged speed that caused his to target you or your vehicle specifically?
Had he made the u-turn in a safe manner, in-line with his department policy and training manual?
Was his body camera on, recording the entire stop?
Did you request to speak with his supervisor on duty?
Was the stop extend longer than was reasonably necessary?
 
You 100% did it right. Treat the officer as a person. Most of the people I summonsed talked themselves into it.
Thank you,
I’m surprised at some of these responses in here that if I was an officer, I would take in a negative way.

People need to lighten up and that’s exactly my point and why my entire life I have had respect for police. I was certainly no angel growing up in the wild 60s and 70s. Partying drinking racing cars up and down Hempstead Turnpike on Long Island. Every time a light turned green.

Police officers are no different than any of us. They have a job to do. Why make their job harder, talk to them and be respectful like a human being who is enforcing the law and don’t make up BS excuses.

You may find that goes a long way.
I have never had a bad experience with a police officer. In case you don’t know, police have family, friends, and children themselves.

One example would be when I was in high school, my last year of high school, I was drunk as a skunk driving my 67 GTO. By the time, I realized it police officer was pulling me over. Minutes later, I was surrounded by police officers. Same deal when they asked if I was drinking, I could hear my words slurring so I told him southern comfort with Coca-Cola. Back then they were always busting kids for drugs in school so they asked me if I had drugs in my car. I said no. They asked for permission to search it. I said yes.

On top of it, the parking lot that I pulled into had a police booth in it. That’s a place where police change shifts.
Sometime later, the police officers partner comes over to me and says I don’t know why my partner is doing this, but we’re going to pull your car next to the police booth, you’re going to leave it there overnight and pick it up in the morning.

In the meantime, they gave me a ride home and actually stopped a couple houses before my house so no one saw me get out of a police car.

At the time I did have a PBA card on my dashboard and a PBA badge in my wallet. Whether or not it may have made a difference I don’t know. The reason for that is, I never pointed it out to them or suggested, nor boasted because I support the PBA and have many friends who are police officers that came into the business where I worked part-time. Once a great while a curious cop would ask back then.

I don’t know maybe because I was going to actually be a police officer on Long Island myself. I actually took the police exam to be what was called at the time, a junior cadet, but another opportunity came up so instead of waiting on a list to be hired I didn’t pursue it anymore.

But for some reason, a good percentage of the public has this confrontational attitude that is uncalled for.
 
Last edited:
Here’s my annoyance with these speed set ups….
You’re going to work, appointment, taking kids somewhere, and on and on…the police will jack you up for speeding. One the other hand a vehicle can have a fake paper tag, no tag, expired tag, stolen tag, no tail lights etc, bumper covers dragging, and - or music so loud with car holding more passengers than seatbelts and they won’t dare pull that over. In most cities, Charlotte, Greensboro, and Raleigh just to name a few in North Carolina, the law enforcement agencies are not ticketing-stopping the above mentioned infractions. It was agreed in these areas that these stops are nothing more than “profiling “. Put whatever adjective-description in front of profiling. But don’t speed going to work to earn a paycheck that is taxed to pay the agency’s salaries…
Speed traps are quick turn revenue streams. The vast majority of "Customers" simply pay out. Disputing the "Bill" is very inconvenient and in the end everyone settles up their "Tab" lest .gov clips your wings.

Localities, backed up by the state, insurance companies and dimly lit rooms full of faceless government officials will cry "Safety" and happily deposit your $ into the general fund.

It's infuriating especially when you see cops all day cruising 10-15 over while typing on a laptop.
 
Last edited:
If these localities were actually serious about speed related safety, when you got caught you would have to take a time out; Say 20 minutes on the side of the road and then some kind of on-line retraining at home. But, this would not generate any revenue... :(
 
Always comply.
So, does this mean a roadside sobriety test?

You know those are fishing expeditions right? I've seen many videos where officers are offended and use every verbal judo trick to convince a person to do a roadside test. Why not just do a breathalyzer right off the bat? I know why, because it helps the police report out substantiating someone is a DUI. Can anyone here read the alphabet backwards...some can't even do it forwards. How about all those DUI cases where the cop stated on body cam they smelled alcohol but the driver blew 0's and now they suspect marijuana?

How about:
  • "Give me your keys" - handing keys over can be interpreted by a prosecutor as permission to search vehicle
  • "Where are you coming from?" - establishes a behavioral baseline to see what you look like when relaxed.
  • "Do you know why I pulled you over?" - extracts a legally binding confession to an infraction immediately.
  • "Whose car is this?" - checks for hesitation to catch mules or stolen vehicles.
  • "Cognitive Load" - forces you to rapidly generate specific details to see if you trip over a lie.
  • "Columbo Technique" - feigns harmless curiosity to lower your defenses so you overshare.
  • "Assumptive Questioning" - asks a question that assumes you are already guilty to trap you into an admission.
  • "Verbal Judo" - uses calm, empathetic tones to gain your voluntary compliance and keep you talking.

I think you are confusing "comply" with "I need to have it my way here" and some do it with a touch of intimidation and aggressiveness.

I'm not saying pull out the cell phone and start screaming "Terry v Ohio".

Of course one should be polite but complying doesn't mean having to incriminate yourself.

A traffic stop should be about X and not psychological games. But no one cares what I have to say. IIRC in CA the officers are supposed to start with the exact reason why they pulled someone over with. Makes sense, no reason into so where are u going today?

It's all a trap, and if you potentially show slight non compliance, a fragile ego might give you a ticket vs a warning if you do incriminate yourself. Darned if u do or you don't.
 
I learned the proper way to interact with the Police, from a Chris Rock instructional video...

I kept that in mind when earlier today I earned a chat with a Norwegian Police officer. I think when he realized we were from the USA, a country which doesn't primarily use the metric system, he cut me some slack. No ticket, just some advice to pay more attention to the speed.
 
Speed traps are quick turn revenue streams. The vast majority of "Customers" simply pay out. Disputing the "Bill" is very inconvenient and in the end everyone settles up their "Tab" lest .gov clips your wings.

Localities, backed up by the state, insurance companies and dimly lit rooms full of faceless government officials will cry "Safety" and happily deposit your $ into the general fund.

It's infuriating especially when you see cops all day cruising 10-15 over while typing on a laptop.
The question is, were you speeding or not?
Everything else is irrelevant. You’re either breaking the law and got caught or you were not.

We are a society with laws in place. We hire professionals to enforce those laws.

I have never been pulled over for speeding when I wasn’t speeding and I don’t know anyone pulled over for speeding and claim they weren’t speeding in my (so far) very long life 🙃

Actually, I don’t know anyone who was unjustly accused of anything that they were not guilty of.
Does it happen? Of course, mistakes are made and in every society we have criminal elements in every profession.
 
Back
Top Bottom