Governed by FAR 91.151. Private Pilots must plan for enough fuel to fly to the point of intended landing, considering wind and weather, and 30 minutes flight time (day), or 45 minutes flight time (night) after that...
This is a case where FAR is really not that relevant.
Look, our SOP for minimum landing fuel, at a field, VFR, was 2,000 lbs.
What's that in minutes?
Is it:
a) 2 trips around the landing pattern, fully configured, or about 15 minutes.
b) 25 minutes of clean holding at best speed.
c) 1 minute in full AB
d) all of the above
Well, of course, it's d. We routinely landed with one minute of fuel, or 25 minutes, or whatever.
The difference in fuel burn in a 172 at best endurance and full power is very small, so that FAR makes sense.
I would declare minimum fuel if I was getting close to 2,000# landing fuel.
I once declared an emergency with Chicago Center. I ultimately landed with 900#. Less than 30 seconds if I were to go AB. Certainly less than 10 minutes normal burn. Center tried to give me a vector off course, to which my RIO asked, "is there something about our 7700 squawk that is unclear?"
Ironically, minutes later, Chicago approach tried to sequence me in behind a C-130 doing a practice approach into NAS Glenview, and I asked, "is that C-130 also an emergency aircraft?" When the controller said, "No", I said, "we have ten minutes of fuel remaining, and you need to get him out of our way."
Controllers are simply not used to how quickly a fighter uses fuel.
"Minimum fuel" is defined in the FAR, yes, but the meaning is very different for a fighter than for a conventional airplane that burns a pretty consistent amount of fuel.
When you are "bingo" you are going to climb at best rate (450 knots, FAR speed limit below 10,000 feet no longer applies) to the appropriate altitude (upper 30s, or higher) cruise at the appropriate mach, and do an idle descent to the field.
We could get from 100 miles out at 3.2 to land at 2.0 by flying the profile. NO turns. No speed restrictions. Straight in approach. Once you get to that fuel, you go, right on the profile, right now.
This guy was "bingo" - he had already committed to the profile. That’s the right thing to do. How he got low on gas doesn’t matter. He was handling it correctly.
And ATC did a GREAT job getting him a tanker vs. him continuing the divert into SYR. Very pro-active and thoughtful.