Originally Posted By: Gary Allan
Unless the pump is in relief (or leaking internally), there is no appreciable PSID across the filter. Hardly any. I'll venture to say that your hot oil pressure is the same regardless of what filter you use. That clearly indicates a reactive impedance.
IMO, and based on fluid dynamics, there will always be some level of PSID across a filter is there is flow across the filter ... regardless if the filter has any back pressure on it or not. A PSID of 10 can be achieved by putting 10 psi on the inlet with 0 psi on the outlet, or by putting 210 psi on the inlet with 200 psi on the outlet ... or any similar combination. The driving force that makes the oil flow is the 10 psi in these examples.
In a case where the oil viscosity is constant, the PSID will go from 0 to some max right along with the developed pump pressure going from 0 to it's relief pressure. The max PSID across the filter will occur at the same time the oil pump goes into relief mode ... as that point is the highest possible oil pressure the pump can supply to the system.
When you say "Unless the pump is in relief (or leaking internally), there is no appreciable PSID across the filter.", there needs to be specific qualifiers associated with that statement. There is always some level of pressure drop across the filter if there is flow through it. That level depends on the volume and viscosity of the flow. If the volume is high and viscosity high (redline with -20 deg F oil - ouch), then the PSID is max ... if the volume is low and viscosity low (hot oil at idle), then the PSID is small and negligible like Gary has indicated. There is a HUGE spectrum of operating conditions going on, so any broad statement need to have the qualifier nailed to it.
Originally Posted By: Gary Allan
The pump is only positive displacement when not in relief.
Well actually, the pump is a positive displacement device regardless if it's in relief or not. The relief valve is on the output side of the pump. When in relief, then a portion of that volume gets spit back into the sump and doesn't get send down stream to the filter/engine circuit.
Originally Posted By: Gary Allan
It is only in relief that it will have the potential to appear like a normal resistive circuit with pressure "drops". Out of relief ..100% of the sensible flow is going through the engine. In that state, there are absolutely no pressure drops ..but pressure elevations back toward the supply.
Not sure I follow ya here - I think it's word semantics and writing style getting in the way. IMO, any time there is flow through the filter/engine circuit there is a pressure drop happening ... both across the filter and across the engine's circuit. Think of the engine's complex oiling circuit as one fixed resistor, which it really is.
Let's say you have a straight section of tubing 10 ft long, and you put 20 psi on one end and 0 psi (vent to ATM) on the other end, then there is a pressure gradient going down the pipe. The pressure is not 20 psi a 1/2" from the vent. If you could put pressure gauges at every 1 foot along the tube, you would see the pressure drop as you went from the 20 psi end to the 0 psi end. Therefore, this 10 ft section of tubing has an effective 20 PSID associated with the flowrate going through it. It took 20 psi to move that fluid volume (ie, GPM) through the tube.
The same is going on in an engine's oiling system. The oil pump supplies say 60 psi to the inlet of the system (inlet to the filter), and the system ultimately vents to ATM (the sump). All along the system as oil flow through it, there are pressure drops that will all add up to 60 psi. Some pressure is lost at the filter, some at each bearing in the engine, etc. The pressure is NOT the same everywhere in the system as there is flowrate through it. Only if you blocked the vent to the system and stopped the flow, then all points in the system would equalize to the same pressure.