Can't decide between Amsoil and Redline

The 3.6 is an old dog that can live on much less fancy oil. Over landing won’t make any difference.
It is said that this 3.6 is the new Pentastar Upgrade(PUG) with a redesigned valvetrain so I am not sure any viscosity other than the 0w-20 is a good idea. Having said that, both Redline and Amsoil 0w-40 are very tempting.
 
Whatever is cheaper?

Mobil 1 ESP 0w-30.
Well, oil is pretty cheap when it comes to cost of ownership.

Based on what the OP is considering, I give the edge to Amsoil SS and jumping up to a 30 grade as others suggest.

I’m sure ESP would do the trick too, but the OP asked between Red Line or Amsoil.

If ever late on an oil change, the Amsoil probably more has more reserve capacity for extending the interval as others have indicated. If keeping the interval short, either would work well.
 
It is said that this 3.6 is the new Pentastar Upgrade(PUG) with a redesigned valvetrain so I am not sure any viscosity other than the 0w-20 is a good idea. Having said that, both Redline and Amsoil 0w-40 are very tempting.
Technically there is no reason any viscosity that flows won’t work. Sure a 40 has a bit higher viscosity at 100°C but the valve train would be just the same with a relatively thinner viscosity oil at say 60°C or whatever temp the viscosity is the same as the SAE 40 oil. Think about it.

And yes sure there is a limit say in the winter cold start.
 
Hello good people! 2025 Jeep Gladiator with 3.6L V6. It will be used for overlanding and daily driving. No intention of towing yet. Will appreciate the pros and cons of Amsoil and Redline 0w-20.
Oh, the Jeep will be modified very soon
Thanks
Redline is the bomb. Love it. You'll be perfectly fine with each but Redline is more robust and Amsoil is focused on extended drain intervals which I'm not a fan of.
 
Technically there is no reason any viscosity that flows won’t work. Sure a 40 has a bit higher viscosity at 100°C but the valve train would be just the same with a relatively thinner viscosity oil at say 60°C or whatever temp the viscosity is the same as the SAE 40 oil. Think about it.

And yes sure there is a limit say in the winter cold start.
If I go 40, I'll definitely go Amsoil. Redline is way too thick. Thanks for the OE idea, I need something less expensive to break in the motor.
 
Redline is the bomb. Love it. You'll be perfectly fine with each but Redline is more robust and Amsoil is focused on extended drain intervals which I'm not a fan of.
Yeah their 40 is nuts.

Screenshot_20250718_154142_Chrome.webp
 
so I am not sure any viscosity other than the 0w-20 is a good idea. Having said that, both Redline and Amsoil 0w-40 are very tempting.
I don't hesitate to go up one grade thicker, i.e. -20 up to -30, but not sure I'd go to -40 unless they spec that for this engine in other regions.
 
The “upgrade” 3.6 has been around in the Jeep Grand Cherokee and the mini vans for several years now. The Wranglers got it last for some reason. With people running heavier weights than xw20 with no issues.

It took me a few months of research to finally make the switch to a thicker oil.

I just switched the Wife’s 21 Jeep GC over to Amsoil 0w-30 and posted a thread on what results I “noticed” on our vacation last week.

That’s what I’m going to stay with. My 21 Hemi Ram is changing from 5w-20 to 5w-30 next oil change. I have a few Pennzoil Ultra Platinum jugs for my Ram that I got on a great deal. When those are done I’ll use Amsoil in it too.
 
The “upgrade” 3.6 has been around in the Jeep Grand Cherokee and the mini vans for several years now. The Wranglers got it last for some reason. With people running heavier weights than xw20 with no issues.

It took me a few months of research to finally make the switch to a thicker oil.

I just switched the Wife’s 21 Jeep GC over to Amsoil 0w-30 and posted a thread on what results I “noticed” on our vacation last week.

That’s what I’m going to stay with. My 21 Hemi Ram is changing from 5w-20 to 5w-30 next oil change. I have a few Pennzoil Ultra Platinum jugs for my Ram that I got on a great deal. When those are done I’ll use Amsoil in it too.
Yeah I saw your post. You said that you were having that dry start problem. That's pretty normal on these motors. If it bothers you, prime the filter each time before you start the Jeep. You will notice a drastic difference.
 
My 2021 Jeep Wrangler(3.6) oil temps got into the 240’s with only moderate off roading. I went to a 0W-30. Both Amsoil and Redline make fantastic oils.
Mine got to 230 driving around town. I have made up my mind, I'm going 30 weight. Doesn't matter how good Amsoil and Redline are, 0w-20 is 0w-20. 40 weight not now, I'll take my time and see how things go
 
Amsoil and Redline 0w-20.
You could add HPL (High Performance Lubricants) to your list if you are willing to spend that kind money. All three are really high-end oils compared to the Majors. I personally would move up to a 0w-30 or 5w-30 though, maybe even a Euro oil to get your HTHS >3.5 or higher. That is just my advice, not saying it is correct. Most people on this site are more knowledgeable about oil than I am. There is an Amsoil dealer right here on Bitog, he is called Pablo. Put his name in the search, he will pop up.
 
Amsoil SS and RL are both very good. If I had to be picky, I'd say Amsoil SS edges RL in longer drain intervals while RL is more shear stable. Amsoil also provides a lot of good data to look at off their site.

If your drain intervals are on the conservative/OEM side, you may just want to grab one of the off-shelf oils.
Do you have KRL results on both oils? Probably can’t say which one is more shear stable without that data, since every single engine will have slightly different fuel dilution, points that may cause VIIs to shear mechanically, etc.

If you do have KRL results, that would be sweet to see! 👍🏻
 
You could add HPL (High Performance Lubricants) to your list if you are willing to spend that kind money. All three are really high-end oils compared to the Majors. I personally would move up to a 0w-30 or 5w-30 though, maybe even a Euro oil to get your HTHS >3.5 or higher. That is just my advice, not saying it is correct. Most people on this site are more knowledgeable about oil than I am. There is an Amsoil dealer right here on Bitog, he is called Pablo. Put his name in the search, he will pop up.
Use the (at) symbol in front, so the people you’re referencing get notified in instances like this… @Pablo or @HPL Plant Manager 😉

Both of them give great customer service, you can’t go wrong with either. 👍🏻
 
smart to stay with 0W20 while in warranty however if your OM says for towing or off-roading you could step up to a 0 or 5W30 then go ahead. Don't think you need unicorn tears such as Amsoil or Redline absolutely nothing Pennzoil Platinum or Mobil 1 ESP cant handle.
 
Back
Top Bottom