If most of your driving is in a straight line, ten seconds at a time: Camaro is a great car.
If you like to turn left and right, and go fast and slow: Everything else.
Kidding aside, this is a very American thread. Americans buy torque and think the quarter mile competition is "racing." The GR86/BRZ and the Miata are the only affordable, naturally aspirated, rwd sports cars out there. They are not perfect, but they put a smile on your face — usually between 15 and 45 mph. They have a little finesse. The rawness, brutality and violence of muscle cars says everything about the American national character.
I love cars. Pick the one that makes you happy. But the OP is comparing two things that really have little in common.