Would you support an American Foreign Legion?

Status
Not open for further replies.
"Okay, call me a negative Nancy, but...didn't the French Foreign Legion once attempt an overthrow of the French democratic government?"

If you murder someone by shooting them or hire someone to shoot them it's still the same offense, the point being that the US has certainly engaged in toppling governments, democratic or otherwise. France didn't have as much ability to topple other governments so I guess they had to look inward for such activity.
 
Originally Posted By: moribundman

- better or more affordable healthcare
- higher live expectancy
- higher standards in education
- personal safety
- friendlier people
- slower way of life without the 24/7 focus on making money


Affordable health care is understandable but in many cases can be minimized by health living (as I'm sure you already do).
Many items on this list are available in rural parts of the country such as where I live in Alabama. This is especially true with the slower way of life.
Higher standards in education is interesting. I went to a school where 20-25% couldn't pass the exit exam but that didn't hamper my ambition to be educated.
 
I just noticed I wrote "live expectancy." I must now drown myself.


I am not going in argue in lieu of those who chose to live elsewhere. I am simply stating that a fairly large number of Americans lives much of out of the year or altogether elsewhere than in the US.

Growing up in a small Bavarian hick hometown, I alone knew three Americans who were permanently living there. Wherever you go, besides North Korea maybe, you will soon stumble across a local American. The list of reasons why many Americans choose to live abroad may give the impression their choice is one out of necessity. I have never met a poor American abroad. If you don't have the funds, you just can't live abroad better than you can at home, unless you are a beach bum. Speaking of which, during my uni days I got to know and American who had lived in South America for a few years doing nothing but surfing. Eventually he went back home and went to uni. Last time I heard from him he was living in Tunis, Tunisia.
 
Coming from someone who has lived in and worked in different parts of the world, there is no place like home. I estimate that 99.9 % of Americans live here because it's about the cheapest nation in the world to live comfortably in. We have our problems, as much as some and less than most.

This might sound like a harsh alliteration, but I have to do nothing more than to throw a rock in my neighborhood to hit an immigrant. The woman down the street is German, there's an Aussie and his New Zealander wife a couple of streets down, several Korean and Thai families, a French woman, one Chinese, two Egyptian families, A Laotian exchange student next door, one guy from Tunisia and his brother-in-law- a Jordanian; and more Mexicans than you could shake a stick at. It's very hard to convince me that Native-born Americans are in a mass exodus to leave this country.

I think this is the typical (and no offense to you Mori, this isn't aimed at you) Euro view of America. My mother's family was from Paris, (and no I'm not half-coward BTW) and I lived there for a couple of years as a kid. The typical Euro-arrogant view of an American living abroad was "Oh, so America's so great they have to come here to live. Hmmph!" Of course this isn't true of all Europeans, but it's more common in France and Germany, and to a lesser extent Sweden and Norway. Living abroad for most of my formative years gave me a deeper understanding of how the world sees us. Of course, as an outsider looking in I may not be the most objective judge of snobbery but it's definitely there.

Running into other wayward Americans out there, I can definitely say that the majority of Americans, if not tied there through military service, are quite wealthy. And rare. In the ten years or so I lived in Europe I encountered maybe five American families. I think the reason so many Americans stay here, and on the inverse, so many Europeans flock here is the ability to make money and KEEP it. With a tax rate as high as 50-75% in some areas, you'd have to be a die-hard patriot to not entertain the notion of living in America, if only to ensure your financial liberty. If you can't make money in America, you're not going to make it anywhere else in the world.

So no, I don't buy this whole "Americans are leaving their country for a better way of life abroad" thing, I believe it is the complete opposite. We Americans love European snobbery, Arabic hatred for our way of life, and Asian countries buying us out lock, stock, and barrel. If we didn't, there would never be any complaints of snobby French waiters, rude convenience store clerks, or the notion that Toyota and Honda build cars better than we Americans. We love it when Deutschland Emigre's point out that we can't make chocolate, beer, and automobiles correctly therefore we fail at existence. It's part of what endears us to them, and them to us. We, as Americans, wouldn't be treated the same in their prospective countries, and we wouldn't expect to be. It's part of what makes us who we are.

I read a few years back a study that showed that for every one American that left to enjoy life in another country, 350 immigrants came to take his place. I don't know if that's still an accurate figure, but it's close enough. So on behalf of all Americans, to all present and future legal immigrants, I say
welcome2.gif


cheers3.gif
34.gif
08.gif
 
Originally Posted By: Oldmoparguy1
Dang rob.

That is well said!

Thank you.
thumbsup2.gif



+1


I think my old credit card bills and health insurance are a small price to pay for 6 digit income.

How many third world expatriates have an oil stash???

Most of the friends I have who went abroad wandered around for a few years because "the US is so oppressive" and everywhere else in the world "they let you do your own thing." Half of them are back here and in high paying jobs once they got their "rebel" streak out of them, selling investments or loans.....


As for Gary's original question, sure, why not? However, not in large enough numbers to comprise a major component of our armed forces. Lest we lose, as Gibbon referred to it, our martial vigor.
 
Originally Posted By: Oldmoparguy1
Dang rob.

That is well said!

Thank you.
thumbsup2.gif



10.gif


Quote:
I think my old credit card bills and health insurance are a small price to pay for 6 digit income.


QFT.
thumbsup2.gif
 
Originally Posted By: kingrob
I estimate that 99.9 % of Americans live here because it's about the cheapest nation in the world to live comfortably in.

The fondess of cheapness is one of the less endearing qualities.


Quote:
This might sound like a harsh alliteration, but I have to do nothing more than to throw a rock in my neighborhood to hit an immigrant.

"Alliteration?" Not now, not ever!
grin2.gif



Quote:
The woman down the street is German, there's an Aussie and his New Zealander wife a couple of streets down, several Korean and Thai families, a French woman, one Chinese, two Egyptian families, A Laotian exchange student next door, one guy from Tunisia and his brother-in-law- a Jordanian; and more Mexicans than you could shake a stick at.

You are merely describing America.

Quote:
It's very hard to convince me that Native-born Americans are in a mass exodus to leave this country.

Oh, I see what you are implying: only native-born Americans are real 'Murrikans, while immigrants that acquired citizenship are just citizens. I get it!
grin2.gif


At this point I give up dissecting the diatribe, which is fraught with preconceived notions. However, one thing I'd like to add is that some, or maybe even many people mix up "going to live abroad" and "emigrating." It's not the necessarily the same thing. I figure you, being an at least half French emigrant who's lived here and there, would know that.
grin2.gif
 
The 1999 numbers for Americans living abroad:

Private American Citizens Residing Abroad
Americans Registered Abroad By Post
(List compiled July 1999 by the Bureau of Consular Affairs)

This list does NOT include U.S. Government (military and nonmilitary) employees and their dependents.

Editor's Note: This list was the last one published. "By Post" means that some countries have both an American embassy and consulate.

Also Note: There is also a report from the Government Accountability Office called '2010 Census: Counting Americans Overseas as Part of the Decennial Census Would Not Be Cost-Effective' which was released on September 14, 2004. This report discusses the number of Americans abroad and the problems with getting accurate statistics.

Americans living in the area of these posts are encouraged to register, which simply means they fill out a form to let the embassy or consulate know they are there. This helps in case of emergencies and situations like lost passports.

Many do not register, which means that in theory the number of Americans could be higher.
These numbers also include children who became American citizens by being born in the United States, but whose parents could be citizens of other countries.

Although this list is from 1999, it still gives a good indication of where Americans are.

Country Post # Resident Americans

ALBANIA Tirana 646

ALGERIA Algiers 793

ANGOLA Luanda 845

ARGENTINA Buenos Aires 27,600

ARMENIA Yerevan 229

AUSTRALIA Canberra 2,500

Melbourne 38,000

Sydney 55,500

Perth 6,800

AUSTRIA Vienna 14,000

AZERBAIJAN Baku 600

BAHAMAS Nassau 7,050

BAHRAIN Manama 1,800

BANGLADESH Dhaka 1,320

BARBADOS Bridgetown 12,000

BELARUS Minsk 190

BELGIUM Brussels 35,328

BELIZE Belize City 2,700

BENIN Cotonou 250

BERMUDA Hamilton 4,300

BOLIVIA La Paz 3,000

BOSNIA-HERZEGOVINA Sarajevo 1600

BOTSWANA Gaborone 800

BRAZIL Brasilia 7,200

Rio de Janeiro 14,460

Sao Paolo 16,480

Recife 2,500

BRUNEI Bandar Seri Begawan 248

BULGARIA Sofia 400

BURKINA FASO Ouagadougou 329

BURMA Rangoon 332

BURUNDI Bujumbura 46

CAMBODIA Phnom Penh 1200

CAMEROON Yaounde 1,161

CANADA Ottawa 24,300

Calgary 105,000

Halifax 40,000

Montreal 65,000

Quebec 3,400

Toronto 250,000

Vancouver 200,000

CAPE VERDE Praia 1,000

CENTRAL AFRICAN REPUBLIC Bangui 91

CHAD N'Djamena 162

CHILE Santiago 11,790

CHINA Beijing 10,000

Guangzhou 3,200

Hong Kong 48,220

Shanghai 2,382

Shenyang 555

Chengdu 800

COLOMBIA Bogota 30,680

CONGO (Democratic Republic of) Kinshasa 440

CONGO (Republic of) Brazzaville 233

COSTA RICA San Jose 19,800

COTE D'IVOIRE Abidjan 2,100

CROATIA Zagreb 1,921

CUBA Havana 2,000

CYPRUS Nicosia 4,175

CZECH REPUBLIC Prague 10,000

DENMARK Copenhagen 9,380

DJIBOUTI Djibouti 50

DOMINICAN REPUBLIC Santo Domingo 82,000

ECUADOR Quito 7,950

Guayquil 5,874

EGYPT Cairo 10,892

EL SALVADOR San Salvador 10,000

EQUATORIAL GUINEA Malabo 30

ERITREA Asmara 356

ESTONIA Tallinn 1,000

ETHIOPIA Addis Ababa 2,190

FIJI Suva 5,288

FINLAND Helsinki 4,700

FRANCE Paris 75,000

Marseille 23,700

Strasbourg 3,050

GABON Libreville 298

GAMBIA Banjul 546

GEORGIA Tbilisi 303

GERMANY Bonn 692

Berlin 14,619

Frankfurt Am Main 138,815

Hamburg 11,754

Munich 45,000


GHANA Accra 3,780

GREECE Athens 65,000

Thessaloniki 7,500

GRENADA St. George's 2,000

GUATEMALA Guatemala City 10,000

GUINEA Conakry 660

GUINEA-BISSAU Bissau 25

GUYANA Georgetown 1,500

HAITI Port-Au-Prince 11,000

HONDURAS Tegucigalpa 10,500

HUNGARY Budapest 15,000

ICELAND Reykjavik 1,730

INDIA New Delhi 1,397

Mumbai 9,400

Calcutta 672

Madras 3,900

INDONESIA Jakarta 6,818

Surabaya 2,240

IRELAND Dublin 46,984

ISRAEL Tel Aviv 18,000

JERUSALEM Jerusalem 76,195

ITALY Rome 40,000

Milan 20,000

Naples 72,000

Florence 36,967

JAMAICA Kingston 7,500

JAPAN Tokyo 45,000

Naha, Okinawa 3,415

Osaka-Kobe 13,484

Sapporo 2,756

Fukuoka 5,695

JORDAN Amman 8,000

KAZAKHSTAN Almaty 3,600

KENYA Nairobi 4,237

KOREA Seoul 30,000

KUWAIT Kuwait 7,710

KYRGYZSTAN Bishkek 150

LAOS Vientiane 293

LATVIA Riga 2,084

LEBANON Beirut 10,000

LESOTHO Maseru 190

LIBERIA Monrovia 220

LITHUANIA Vilnius 1,500

LUXEMBOURG Luxembourg 1,527

MACEDONIA Skopje 800

MADAGASCAR Antananarivo 372

MALAWI Lilongwe 863

MALAYSIA Kuala Lumpur 6,639

MALI Bamako 460

MALTA Valletta 700

MARSHALL ISLANDS Majuro 580

MAURITANIA Nouakchott 100

MAURITIUS Port Louis 320

MEXICO Mexico City 441,680

Ciudad Juarez 63,480

Guadalajara 111,100

Monterrey 29,900

Tijuana 196,000

Hermosillo 80,600

Matamoros 60,960

Merida 49,000

Nuevo Laredo 3,580

MICRONESIA Kolonia 760

MOLDOVA Chisinau 125

MONGOLIA Ulaanbaatar 450

MOROCCO Rabat 1,401

MOZAMBIQUE Maputo 641

NAMIBIA Windhoek 350

NEPAL Kathmandu 1,600

NETHERLANDS Amsterdam 23,707

NETHERLANDS ANTILLES Curacao 6,075

NEW ZEALAND Auckland 14,540

NICARAGUA Managua 5,000

NIGER Niamey 335

NIGERIA Lagos 10,000

NORWAY Oslo 15,000

OMAN Muscat 1,444

PAKISTAN Islamabad 506

Karachi 2,100

Lahore 1,250

Peshawar 375

PALAU Koror 300

PANAMA Panama City 19,700

PAPUA NEW GUINEA Port Moresby 2,468

PARAGUAY Asuncion 2,368

PERU Lima 14,143

PHILIPPINES Manila 105,000

POLAND Warsaw 21,300

Krakow 18,000

PORTUGAL Lisbon 1,072

Ponta Delgada 1,100

QATAR Doha 3,775

ROMANIA Bucharest 13,152

RUSSIA Moscow 8,000

St. Petersburg 900

Vladivostok 348

Yekaterinburg 200

RWANDA Kigali 165

SAUDI ARABIA Riyadh 11,506

Dhahran 13,600

Jeddah 10,883

SENEGAL Dakar 791

SERBIA-MONTENEGRO Belgrade 4,514

SIERRA LEONE Freetown 130

SINGAPORE Singapore 15,000

SLOVAK REPUBLIC Bratislava 850

SLOVENIA Ljubljana 650

SOMALIA Mogadishu 12

SOUTH AFRICA Pretoria 8,100

Cape Town 2,647

Durban 720

SPAIN Madrid 75,596

Barcelona 18,917

SRI LANKA Colombo 658

SUDAN Khartoum 1,479

SURINAME Paramaribo 425

SWAZILAND Mbabane 352

SWEDEN Stockholm 18,000

SWITZERLAND Bern 12,113

SYRIA Damascus 3,856

TAIWAN Taipei 38,000

TAJIKISTAN Dushanbe 117

TANZANIA Dar Es Salaam 1,186

THAILAND Bangkok 16,500

Chiang Mai 1,600

TOGO Lome 329

TRINIDAD & TOBAGO Port-of-Spain 3,200

TUNISIA Tunis 700

TURKEY Ankara 2,010

Istanbul 4,800

Adana 266

TURKMENISTAN Ashgabat 107

UGANDA Kampala 1,350

UKRAINE Kiev 3,000

UNITED ARAB EMIRATES

Abu Dhabi 7,500

Dubai 9,000

UNITED KINGDOM London, England 200,000

Belfast, Ireland 4,000

Edinburgh, Scotland 20,000

URUGUAY Montevideo 3,500

UZBEKISTAN Tashkent 590

VENEZUELA Caracas 25,000

VIETNAM Hanoi 3,000

WESTERN SAMOA Apia 495

YEMEN Sanaa 15,300

ZAMBIA Lusaka 980

ZIMBABWE Harare 2,125



GRAND TOTAL 3,784,693
 
I'm surprised Gary hasn't uttered the word "sleeper" yet.

The woods are lovely, dark and deep
But I have promises to keep
And miles to go before I sleep

(reference to Telefon )
 
Quote:
The fondess of cheapness is one of the less endearing qualities.


Actually, it is.



Quote:
"Alliteration?" Not now, not ever!


Sorry, the American Education system failed me yet again.
frown.gif



Quote:
You are merely describing America.


Your report cites just over three and a half million Americans living abroad. Compare to the Thirty Three and a half million foreign born citizens living in the US (http://www.census.gov/prod/2004pubs/p20-551.pdf) and you'll see this disparaging hole in your theory of a mass exodus. If America is so bad, why are only three million Americans in another country but thirty three million people from another country HERE? Doesn't hardly seem like such a desolate wasteland if everyone is flocking to live here and nobody is leaving.

And just to poke fun a little at Der Fazerland's expense, why is there over 3 million German born American citizens living here now compared to the 200,000 Americans living in Germany?
whistle.gif



Quote:
Oh, I see what you are implying: only native-born Americans are real 'Murrikans, while immigrants that acquired citizenship are just citizens. I get it!


Well, Jingoistic Nationalism is not something I've ever been privy to here in the states. Not the same thing can be said for certain Euro movements I've witnessed firsthand... But I digress.

You're here in a very open way painting me a racial or cultural elitist for stating the fact that people born in the US are not beating down the doors of other countries to seek refuge. That's pretty sleazy.

Quote:
However, one thing I'd like to add is that some, or maybe even many people mix up "going to live abroad" and "emigrating." It's not the necessarily the same thing. I figure you, being an at least half French emigrant who's lived here and there, would know that.
grin2.gif



You're right, I lived abroad.
grin2.gif
 
Originally Posted By: kingrob
your theory of a mass exodus.


Don't put words in my mouth, I never said there was a mass exodus, as I already have pointed out.

Quote:
And just to poke fun a little at Der Fazerland's expense, why is there over 3 million German born American citizens living here now compared to the 200,000 Americans living in Germany?
whistle.gif


Clearly they don't care for the weather in Germany! As for why they got US citizenship, I presume they plan on reaping the benefit of being a citizen some day.


Quote:
You're here in a very open way painting me a racial or cultural elitist for stating the fact that people born in the US are not beating down the doors of other countries to seek refuge. That's pretty sleazy.

That's your interpretation of what I said? Tu es fou?
LOL.gif


Quote:
You're right, I lived abroad.
grin2.gif



So have I since I was 5. Here, there, and over there.
wink.gif
 
Quote:
That's your interpretation of what I said? Tu es fou?


Peut-être,

Quote:
Oh, I see what you are implying: only native-born Americans are real 'Murrikans


But I don't see any other way to take that comment. I wasn't implying anything other than what I stated, yet you fell back on the common worldwide assumed stereotype of the American elitist cowboy that doesn't consider someone a fellow countryman unless he's the right "stock". C'est la vie, said the cowboy.
 
Originally Posted By: kingrob
American elitist cowboy


First an "alliteration," now a contradictio in adjecto! Way to go, mon ami!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom