When the dealer says your cabin air filter's dirty

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not all $tealers go by time. The local Honda $tealership has a check list that states inspect engine air filter, and of course after I got the car back I went to see if they had actually removed the air box cover and looked at the air filter, they had absolutely NOT inspected that filter because one of the screws was actually rusted and seized in place! And you had to remove that faster before you could get a look at this filter at ALL!

This is why $tealers get the rep they do, they EARN it. Most are incompetent and/ or crooked.
 
Originally Posted By: salv
Originally Posted By: THE_TROTS
No dealership tech is checking your filters during the free multi-point inspections included with an oil change. No dealership tech is changing your oil unless it is part of a repair.

Dealers have a fast lane/quick lube/whatever you want to call it staff who's entire jobs are to change oil. The fast lane/quick lube/whatever it is called employees are the ones who would check that filter during your inspection, and many don't. They are judged by the service manager mostly on how fast they can turn out oil changes, and tearing apart a dash/glove box to check the cabin air filter can take as long as the oil change itself did.

If you have a service history at that dealership, the service adviser will see that filter as a recommended item based on mileage. If you don't, and it was later recommended, than the fast lane employee who changed your oil took the time to check it.

Yes, if the filter was actually checked, than he did tear into the dash to check it. In regards to the price, that's part of dealer service. It is worth it to some, not to others. There's a reason dealer service departments often make more money than the new car sales department.


This is not only wrong in many cases, but a huge overgeneralization. At my shop it is our job as service advisors to check fluids before the RO is written. Many shops operate that way.

Our technicians will check cabin filters if they suspect they haven't been changed, or if they hear something rattling around in the blower. Any smart tech knows that giving a customer a visual is going to increase their chances of selling a job.

Only larger dealers have quick lube lines.


Well [censored] my [censored] and call me a [censored]. I did not know there existed service advisers willing to get their hands dirty, or techs willing to perform mere quick lube tasks. My eyes have never witnessed either.
 
Originally Posted By: ryanschillinger
Then you don't have to worry about stuff coming undone behind your glovebox when they slap it back together...


+1 or the idiot tech leaving the cover off and then you have to guy a new one.
mad.gif
 
Had that happen. Stealer told me the filter was dirty. I said "thank you" and denied the service. When I went to change it, it wasn't there, and there was no evidence that the door to the compartment had been removed. I assumed the car was delivered without it.

It took me mo more than 2 minutes to install (not replace because there wasn't one there).
 
Interesting replies, guys. Some people asked what cars I was talking about-- the Accord and Infiniti.

I changed both cars' filters during the holidays. Both involved removing the panel from the passenger foot well area and the glove compartments. Not difficult, just annoying. I'm glad I replaced them because they were pretty dirty. Used OEM Honda filters from the dealer since the local parts stores were sold out and Napa Gold filters for the Infiniti.

Originally Posted By: SevenBizzos
Had that happen. Stealer told me the filter was dirty. I said "thank you" and denied the service. When I went to change it, it wasn't there, and there was no evidence that the door to the compartment had been removed. I assumed the car was delivered without it.

It took me mo more than 2 minutes to install (not replace because there wasn't one there).

Had a similar thing happen to me with my old Elantra. The tech at the dealership came out with my supposedly dirty cabin filter saying it needed replacement. I denied and went on my merry way. I went to change it the next month and noticed the filter was missing altogether. Either I never had one to begin with and the dealership was showing me some other car's dirty filter, or they just ripped mine out out of spite since I denied their $80 replacement. Either way, stealerships can all go pound sand.
 
Originally Posted By: mclasser
Interesting replies, guys. Some people asked what cars I was talking about-- the Accord and Infiniti.


Had a similar thing happen to me with my old Elantra. The tech at the dealership came out with my supposedly dirty cabin filter saying it needed replacement. I denied and went on my merry way. I went to change it the next month and noticed the filter was missing altogether. Either I never had one to begin with and the dealership was showing me some other car's dirty filter, or they just ripped mine out out of spite since I denied their $80 replacement. Either way, stealerships can all go pound sand.


LOL. That was the car in question for me too. An '04 Elantra.

That began quite the relationship between the stealer and I. After catching them in 5-6 more lies, we permanently parted ways.
 
Both my Accord and Civic take less than 3 minutes to change. Just squeeze the two sides of the glovebox inward and it flips down. The cabin air filter just slides out. Easy Peasy. Took me longer to type this than change.
 
Originally Posted By: mclasser

Had a similar thing happen to me with my old Elantra. The tech at the dealership came out with my supposedly dirty cabin filter saying it needed replacement. I denied and went on my merry way. I went to change it the next month and noticed the filter was missing altogether. Either I never had one to begin with and the dealership was showing me some other car's dirty filter, or they just ripped mine out out of spite since I denied their $80 replacement. Either way, stealerships can all go pound sand.


Don't be too surprised either, I have noticed a number of times that when you refuse service they will often times retaliate by breaking things, and or removing parts! Quite common as far as my experiences go. DO NOT TRUST ANY OF THEM!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom