Toyota 4.0L VVt vs 4.0L dual VVt

Joined
Jun 12, 2005
Messages
6,392
Location
North Texas
Toyotas single VVt requires 5W30 where’s as their dual VVt requires 0W20. Could I go with 5W30 in the dual VVt. Thanks.
 
Did you knife it could pump a t 0F rating it would have to be labeled as a 0w rating
Not necessarily. They're both thin energy conserving oils. Mobil 1 EP HM 5W-30 is a PAO+mPAO+GTL blend, while PUP 5W-30 is all GTL.

Take a look at the PUP 5W-30 PDS bellow. There is enough room there to pass ASTM D5293 at -35C, guaranteed.

1717889205037.jpg
 
Did you know if it could pump at 0F rating it would have to be labeled as a 0w rating.
SAE J300 defines the W grades. 0W is defined as the CCS dynamic viscosity being 6200 cP or less at -35C (-31F). 5W is defined as the CCS dynamic viscosity being 6600 cP or less at -30C (-22F). 0W doesn't mean it's good to 0 degrees F. Most oil viscosity recommendation charts in OMs show that 5W-xx can be used below 0F, maybe down to -20F. Would have to look at each vehicle manufacter's recommendation that lists more than one viscosity because some manufactuers will be conservative and cut back the low temp from the miniums defined by J300 - ie, they may say the minimum cold temp for 5W-xx is -10F instead of -20F.

The 2015 verson of J300 shown below is the latest version, it hasn't been updated since 2015.

1717892240063.jpeg
 
SAE J300 defines the W grades. 0W is defined as the CCS dynamic viscosity being 6200 cP or less at -35C (-31F). 5W is defined as the CCS dynamic viscosity being 6600 cP or less at -30C (-22F). 0W doesn't mean it's good to 0 degrees F. Most oil viscosity recommendation charts in OMs show that 5W-xx can be used below 0F, maybe down to -20F. Would have to look at each vehicle manufacter's recommendation that lists more than one viscosity because some manufactuers will be conservative and cut back the low temp from the miniums defined by J300 - ie, they may say the minimum cold temp for 5W-xx is -10F instead of -20F.

The 2015 verson of J300 shown below is the latest version, it hasn't been updated since 2015.

View attachment 223835

Da*n it 15W40 is actually thicker then 0/5-W40 😁
 
SAE J300 defines the W grades. 0W is defined as the CCS dynamic viscosity being 6200 cP or less at -35C (-31F). 5W is defined as the CCS dynamic viscosity being 6600 cP or less at -30C (-22F). 0W doesn't mean it's good to 0 degrees F. Most oil viscosity recommendation charts in OMs show that 5W-xx can be used below 0F, maybe down to -20F. Would have to look at each vehicle manufacter's recommendation that lists more than one viscosity because some manufactuers will be conservative and cut back the low temp from the miniums defined by J300 - ie, they may say the minimum cold temp for 5W-xx is -10F instead of -20F.

The 2015 verson of J300 shown below is the latest version, it hasn't been updated since 2015.

View attachment 223835
My statement should have been a 0W rating not F typing fast and busy
 
I was refering to HTHS being 3.7 instead of 3.5.

Higher winter grade is not thicker in my book.
Higher W grade is certainly a concern in cold start-up weather, so it shouldn't be ignored. At the same cold temp, a 15W is certainly thicker than lower W rated oils. There's a reason that the W grade was invented and defined by SAE J300. Even two xW-40 oil grades can have different KV100 or HTHS viscosity since the grades are ranges, not specific numbers. Plus, the HTHS viscosity can be effected by the VII package in the oil, as the level and kind of VIs can effect the temporary oil viscosity under high shear rates.
 
Higher W grade is certainly a concern in cold start-up weather, so it shouldn't be ignored. At the same cold temp, a 15W is certainly thicker than lower W rated oils. There's a reason that the W grade was invented and defined by SAE J300. Even two xW-40 oil grades can have different KV100 or HTHS viscosity since the grades are ranges, not specific numbers. Plus, the HTHS viscosity can be effected by the VII package in the oil, as the level and kind of VIs can effect the temporary oil viscosity under high shear rates.

Yeah but who runs their engine cold for more then 10min?
10W40 is not usefully thicker then 0W40. Could argue 15W40 is with slightly higher min. HTHS.
All good certs has stay in grade requirements VII is a non issue.
 
Last edited:
Yeah but who runs their engine cold for more then 10min?
10W40 is not usefully thicker then 0W40. Could argue 15W40 is with slightly higher min. HTHS.
10 minutes of engine running after a very cold start-up using the wrong W grade isn't doing your engine any favors, and could lead to excess start-up wear.

10W-40 is not usually thicker than 0W-40 at cold temps? Is that what you're saying? If so, that's not true. A 10W will be thicker at the same cold temp than a 0W. A 0W made it to the 0W grade for a reason. Talking about W grades and KV100 and HTHS viscosity are all different discussions.
 
10 minutes of engine running after a very cold start-up using the wrong W grade isn't doing your engine any favors, and could lead to excess start-up wear.

10W-40 is not usually thicker than 0W-40 at cold temps? Is that what you're saying? If so, that's not true. A 10W will be thicker at the same cold temp than a 0W. A 0W made it to the 0W grade for a reason.

No im saying there is no benefit to 10W40 over 0W40.
 
Back
Top