To EV or not to EV

...again...forgetting that it lowers monthly cost of electricity significantly and that electricity costs tend to rise while system payments on solid fixed APR do not...
All do-able on an excel spreadsheet. The installers usually provide a pay back schedule and assume a rate of increase. It would be interesting to see an actual, and we can all throw back some Champaign the day Jeff pays out his system with the savings.
 
...again...forgetting that it lowers monthly cost of electricity significantly and that electricity costs tend to rise while system payments on solid fixed APR do not...


Yes but there has to be a break even point when those savings equal the cost of the system. That is several years down the road.

Another analogy would be to spend $20,000 for a well in order to have “free”water.


Nothing is free.
 
......once you pay off your $12,000 capital cost for the solar system. ;)
Sure; the solar project was an investment with an expected return. And a hedge against rising CA energy costs. EV charging is pure added value to the solar project. You may have heard energy cost around here is some of the highest in our nation; my recurring monthly cost is $9 per month regardless of how much electricity I consume, up to production calculated on an annual basis.

It would be difficult to measure the investment. I use far more electricity now, due to retirement, pandemic work form home, etc. Previously I rarely used the AC unless guests were over. Now I do what I want. And electricity costs have sky rocketed around here. Did I mention I hate PG&E?

It is fair to say I love my solar; it has far exceeded expectations and break even calculations.
 
Last edited:
Yes but there has to be a break even point when those savings equal the cost of the system. That is several years down the road.

Another analogy would be to spend $20,000 for a well in order to have “free”water.


Nothing is free.
In my case, the solar project is an investment with an expected return. Better than free.
 
All do-able on an excel spreadsheet. The installers usually provide a pay back schedule and assume a rate of increase. It would be interesting to see an actual, and we can all throw back some Champaign the day Jeff pays out his system with the savings.
I have an actual. I pay about $1400/year more than before I went solar, however, this is data that doesn't tell the whole story, as I took the $11K I got off my taxes that year and did other things with it. Had I not, then my electricity project would have me in the black by a hair instead of the red, but I'm good with it.

What it gives me is stability against potential rising costs.
 
Does it really matter if it is 11 sec or 20 sec, if you don't live on a drag strip it is useless. Depending on where you the roads are more like those of a war torn country where an old deuce and a half would be the best vehicle. I drove in Worcester, MA the other day it was more like downtown Kiev than a modern city.
That depends on what you want. An 11 second car like the Model 3 Performance is more of a want than an need. No one needs a 68 Corvette L36 Roadster or an original 98K 65 4-4-2.
68 new top side.webp

1687098127167.webp
 
Yes but there has to be a break even point when those savings equal the cost of the system. That is several years down the road.

Another analogy would be to spend $20,000 for a well in order to have “free”water.


Nothing is free.

Correct - but at what point does the ROI doing it become a no brainer?

Thats diff number for everyone, but for Californians its sooner than most except maybe Hawaiians.

In my case that was when the ROI breakeven became 5-6 years netting me about 20 years of "paid for" productivity.

Changes to the property and additional electrical load they impose have accelerated the payback.

Funny you bring up water - as storing and pumping irrigation water is one of the accelerators in my ROI.

Most people dont know about 20% of the total amount of electricity generated in Cali is used to move and pump water.
 
Correct - but at what point does the ROI doing it become a no brainer?

Thats diff number for everyone, but for Californians its sooner than most except maybe Hawaiians.

In my case that was when the ROI breakeven became 5-6 years netting me about 20 years of "paid for" productivity.

Changes to the property and additional electrical load they impose have accelerated the payback.

Funny you bring up water - as storing and pumping irrigation water is one of the accelerators in my ROI.

Most people dont know about 20% of the total amount of electricity generated in Cali is used to move and pump water.
BTW, that recent change to NEM we discussed, where they now pay basically the wholesale equivalent? Remember how I said the reason was to drive people to buy systems that came with batteries? It has done exactly that. Folks are trying to avoid exporting at $0.04/kWh and are storing the power to use during the demand peaks where solar isn't contributing.

If only Cali had done this earlier, the duck curve wouldn't be as bad as it is and rates wouldn't have gotten quite as nutty. They'd still be bad, because it's Cali, but they'd be less bad, lol.
 
Yes but there has to be a break even point when those savings equal the cost of the system. That is several years down the road.

Another analogy would be to spend $20,000 for a well in order to have “free”water.


Nothing is free.
People often conveniently forget to factor that into their cost to operate an EV estimate. In some states the break even point happens a lot later than in other states, that all has to be accounted for.
 
Wanting it and
That depends on what you want. An 11 second car like the Model 3 Performance is more of a want than an need. No one needs a 68 Corvette L36 Roadster or an original 98K 65 4-4-2.
View attachment 162012
View attachment 162013
Wanting it and being able to actually drive it for any number of reasons are 2 different things. Those old car were nice but not really fast cars other than red light racing at that time, today a 3.5 Honda Odyssey van with blow either one of them away (I know that to be true).
 
BTW, that recent change to NEM we discussed, where they now pay basically the wholesale equivalent? Remember how I said the reason was to drive people to buy systems that came with batteries? It has done exactly that. Folks are trying to avoid exporting at $0.04/kWh and are storing the power to use during the demand peaks where solar isn't contributing.

If only Cali had done this earlier, the duck curve wouldn't be as bad as it is and rates wouldn't have gotten quite as nutty. They'd still be bad, because it's Cali, but they'd be less bad, lol.

Pretty much yup....what Jeff K and I have is no more.

Silly contracts didnt help, but because " california" the rates are going to be nutty here regardless.
We have to pay more because of their mismanagement.

Where you come from utilities are state run beneficial orgs that mostly have the publics interest in mind - here they are public companies with their own petty interests front and center. They burn down our forests because they are too cheap to maintain and or bury the lines then send us a bill for it concurrently.

As we discussed the state pulled a hat trick and now gets its production for free from new housing, and this one move basically killed retrofit solar in this state. They got the balance wrong.

In talking to the local installers forcing everyone into batteries has fallen on its face.
It's pushing people that can afford them to vote for grid defection -

After all when I no longer need the grid why should I pay for everyone else's problem?

I predict the duck curve will flatten and they will be back to begging and paying for the free generation they used to get.
 
Pretty much yup....what Jeff K and I have is no more.

Silly contracts didnt help, but because " california" the rates are going to be nutty here regardless.
We have to pay more because of their mismanagement.

Where you come from utilities are state run beneficial orgs that mostly have the publics interest in mind - here they are public companies with their own petty interests front and center. They burn down our forests because they are too cheap to maintain and or bury the lines then send us a bill for it concurrently.

As we discussed the state pulled a hat trick and now gets its production for free from new housing, and this one move basically killed retrofit solar in this state. They got the balance wrong.

In talking to the local installers forcing everyone into batteries has fallen on its face.
It's pushing people that can afford them to vote for grid defection -

After all when I no longer need the grid why should I pay for everyone else's problem?

I predict the duck curve will flatten and they will be back to begging and paying for the free generation they used to get.
My electric company is a co-op run and owned by people with my same areacode. Net metering, as well.
 
Not to be too "rub it in your face" to the Cali folks, but these are our current rates, yes, they've gone DOWN.
Screen Shot 2023-06-11 at 11.32.05 AM.webp


While we haven't completely recovered from the Green Energy Act disaster, things are headed in the right direction.

If you convert those current rates to USD, that's 0.053/0.076/0.113 per kWh.

The province is currently looking at building more nukes, so we'll see how that looks probably in the next year or two.
 
Not to be too "rub it in your face" to the Cali folks, but these are our current rates, yes, they've gone DOWN.

View attachment 162032

While we haven't completely recovered from the Green Energy Act disaster, things are headed in the right direction.

If you convert those current rates to USD, that's 0.053/0.076/0.113 per kWh.

The province is currently looking at building more nukes, so we'll see how that looks probably in the next year or two.

Dirt cheap.

Here's where we are.

It's so expensive you can almost do it on your own and if they make us buy batteries there is no point in staying connected anymore.

Screenshot 2023-06-18 at 9.11.30 AM.png
 
Not to be too "rub it in your face" to the Cali folks, but these are our current rates, yes, they've gone DOWN.
View attachment 162032

While we haven't completely recovered from the Green Energy Act disaster, things are headed in the right direction.

If you convert those current rates to USD, that's 0.053/0.076/0.113 per kWh.

The province is currently looking at building more nukes, so we'll see how that looks probably in the next year or two.
Very similar to our rates here in Wisconsin. Mine only does flat fee pricing, but it comes out to 13 cents per kwh. Makes it very easy to decide on driving an EV here.
 
Wanting it and

Wanting it and being able to actually drive it for any number of reasons are 2 different things. Those old car were nice but not really fast cars other than red light racing at that time, today a 3.5 Honda Odyssey van with blow either one of them away (I know that to be true).
Sure. They were great in their time, but today they are collectors. And I believe even that is losing interest.
My point is, for the most part cars are emotional buys. No one needs a Vette, Porsche, Tesla, BMW, MBZ, Bro Dozer, you name it.
An older Civic or Accord, or an older pickup is the smart buy. I say that because that's what I drove while saving and investing for the future. And it worked.
 
Sure. They were great in their time, but today they are collectors. And I believe even that is losing interest.
My point is, for the most part cars are emotional buys. No one needs a Vette, Porsche, Tesla, BMW, MBZ, Bro Dozer, you name it.
An older Civic or Accord, or an older pickup is the smart buy. I say that because that's what I drove while saving and investing for the future. And it worked.
I gotta believe that 11 second quarters in the Vette are a symphony of experience while 11 second quarters in a Tesla are just a hard push in the seat.

Same result, totally different experience.

An 11 second quarter in my Wife’s SL is accompanied by the song of the V-12, and a couple shifts. It’s wonderful.

There are a lot of things that appeal to me about electric propulsion - but the acceleration isn’t anywhere the top of the list. Devoid of the accompaniment - does it really matter?
 
I gotta believe that 11 second quarters in the Vette are a symphony of experience while 11 second quarters in a Tesla are just a hard push in the seat.

Same result, totally different experience.

An 11 second quarter in my Wife’s SL is accompanied by the song of the V-12, and a couple shifts. It’s wonderful.

There are a lot of things that appeal to me about electric propulsion - but the acceleration isn’t anywhere the top of the list. Devoid of the accompaniment - does it really matter?
I have come to appreciate the silent, "right now" pull of the Model 3. I will never do a qtr mile or 0-60 run, but I merge onto freeways and change lanes all the time. No hunting for a gear, no lag, just pull. I am interested in driveability in the real world relevant range.
I would not have said this when we bought the car, or even a year ago. Now I have zero interest in buying another ICE car. Again, this is just me, but I find other cars Old Skool. Not bad, just seem dated. I know this sounds silly, but that's where I am now. Each to their own.
 
I gotta believe that 11 second quarters in the Vette are a symphony of experience while 11 second quarters in a Tesla are just a hard push in the seat.

Same result, totally different experience.

An 11 second quarter in my Wife’s SL is accompanied by the song of the V-12, and a couple shifts. It’s wonderful.

There are a lot of things that appeal to me about electric propulsion - but the acceleration isn’t anywhere the top of the list. Devoid of the accompaniment - does it really matter?

I find the excitement to be similar, sure a roaring small or big block adds, but fast electrics makes that level of performance accessible and livable.

I never had an 11 second car that had superior manners and handling to these.
As you said the big turbo V12 benzes pull like this.
Thats the level you have to spend and maintain in the ICE world for similar level of performance.

For reference 1100 CC bikes delivered this speed starting in the 80's.

There are million on min posts with poeple laughing and smiling when they get that kick in the seat - many for the first time.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom