I would go Michelin.
Before I retired my NHS Trust used Goodyear tyres for probably 20 years, when the Ambulance fleet moved from LDV Convoys with the V8 engine to 2.7cdi Sprinters the problem with shoulder wear become apparent.
They changed over to Michelins in 2007 and the shoulder wear on the Sprinters stopped overnight, I think they were running the G26 tyre?? But the Michelins lasted better and as far as the Response Cars went the Astra hatchbacks were fine on Michelin Energy but the Mk2 Zafira (small 7 seat mpv) was very twitchy on the few that had Energys fitted, most were fitted with the Primacy HP tyre and much better than any of the GoodYears, they had used Gooryear NCT 5s, Goodyear Fast Response and GoodYear Excellence over the years.
Michelin have just brought out the new Energy + and Primacy 3. Apparently the Energy + has been improved to deal with the dismal wet grip.
The Energy was fine for normal use, but not for blue light response driving.