Hello, Remember to place your Craigslist ad in several regions. Even though CR has an "or near by" function, it helps to spread it around. Hudson Valley, Albany, Catskills (I don't know exactly where you are).
Just hold your ground on price but do have a realistic price in mind. Darn near everybody thinks their vehicles are worth more than they are. Here's where it pays to have kept records.
If you're near the Champlain Valley use the Whitehall times as that paper goes up both sides of Lake Champlain. My friends have used it with great success. On several occasions lads from Vermont answer an ad. They show up with cash and a pair of plates. On go the plates and away goes the car. Never heard of a problem.
Also, the Denton papers are 11 or 13 local shoppers which have gotten results for me. The coverage is quite thick in the region.
You're by Lake Placid, right? Good luck with the sales.