Redicoulus Cabin Filter Price

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Apr 17, 2006
Messages
19,528
Location
Lake Forest, CA
Why some cabin filters are so much more expensive than engine air filter of the same car ?

Example, 2005 Chevrolet Upland Mann cabin filter MC10092 is $23.79 at Rockauto, while Mann engine air filter MA1011 is $3.95.

Yes, there are 2 cabin filters in a package and it is charcoal type, but the price is still too high.
 
That's actually an OK price. Cabin air filters are not the same as engine air filters, the two cannot really be compared. $20-35 for a cabin filter is pretty standard.
 
I've found generally that the words 'rediculous price' and 'cabin filter' just seem to go together.

I've bought my replacements from Advance using either the $10 off $25 coupon or an online code.

For what they are, their cost is whacked!
 
Try washing the filter in dish washing detergent in water.Dry with a vaccum cleaner-This should work if done carefully.
 
It's not a terrible price. Have you checked local vendors like WM for it? I think I got mine from WM for like 18 dollars. I don't remember if it was charcoal or just reg white.
 
I actually bought 2 packs Mann charcoal cabin filter MC10092 from Amazon for $3.56 a pack, since I bought something else for $25.xx I got free shipping. It was that low price because they had only 2 packs remaining. When I saw the price of $23.79 for a pack on Rockauto, I bought the remaining 2 packs because of the low price.
 
Quote:

try my luck- charcoal filters for '01 M-B are $95 if you buy OEM Meyle I believe it is.


Yes, but they filter blister, nerve and choking agents....
 
Originally Posted By: MrMeeks
Try washing the filter in dish washing detergent in water.Dry with a vaccum cleaner-This should work if done carefully.


I did this and it's worked well so far. The charcoal is probably depleted or was washed away during the cleaning, but the my vents smell of air and nothing else, so I guess it worked well enough.
 
Walmart just started stocking Fram cabin filters and they seem to be high there also but knowing Walmart they might be able to drive the price down or at least stablize it.

Personally, I remove my filters once or twice a year and remove the heavy stuff with a brush and air compressor and then re-insert. Never thought to wash them since they dont advertise that they are washable.

Remember the charcoal is for odor control and and not filtration. Even 3M charges top dollar for their best furnace filters which are impregnated with charcoal for odor control.

I agree. I think we are being ripped off on these items.

Rich K
------------------------------
2004 Lexus RX330 (72,000m)
2003 Honda CRV (84,000m)
 
You are talking a low demand, high variation in size, specialty item. It will take a while to get down to what we expect.
 
I can buy 3 of the highest efficiency, best quality HVAC filters for my house for the price of one cabin air filter for my 6 at Pep-Boys.

I tried a HEPA filter for a vacuum. It was the right size and seemed to filter well but didn't seem to flow very well. Maybe I had it in backwards.
 
Originally Posted By: Spazdog
I can buy 3 of the highest efficiency, best quality HVAC filters for my house for the price of one cabin air filter for my 6 at Pep-Boys.


I buy the highest efficiency 3M furnace filter for less than the price of one cabin filter, and then cut it down to size (sealing it with small strips of duct tape). Doing this can get you four cabin filters for less than the price of one.
 
Quote:
check specific websites for your car. I know the pontiac vibe forum, there was a link posted on where to get cheap cabin air filters for under $5. this company may sell for other makes cabin air filters.

P.S here's the link for a 06 vibe cabin air filter for $3.62

http://logical-source.com/2006-PONTIAC-VIBE-7587.html
Yes the Logical-Source has some of, if not the best everyday prices online or store. Problem is the shipping costs. Best way to by from them is to buy several filters or for several cars as it spreads the shipping cost out, and it doesn't increase much after the one filter purchase price.
 
The Japanese auto manufacturers, I believe, where the ones who first used these CABIN FILTERS.

Its just a matter of time before all mfgs. use these filters and its at that time that the price should come down to something reasonable.

Unless you smoke or live in a heavy polluted area like China, these charcoal impregnated cabin filters only catched heavy debris like leaves and small items.

I personally think its a good idea for the auto's HVAC system, but the prices are still too high. Our furnace HVAC filters can be bought with or without charcoal but the main reason these filters exist, is to protect the A/C coils down stream. Unless you do alot of greasy cooking or have a habit of opening your windows and allowing the pollutants to enter, charcoal filters are overkill.

But I am of the age that I can remember motor oil for less than $1.00 per quart and gasoline for 20cents per gallon and now its hard to find any brand or any viscosity or type for less than $4-5.00 per quart. Gasoline prices flucuates, but the price of motor oil stays the same. Shame on the refiners.

The only good thing is that oil change intervals are being extended from 3000miles to 5000miles or 10,000miles. With better filtration we may see even more extended intervals.

My son had about a 1980 Pontiac Booneville and he used Mobil 1. But back then we were told to change oil every 25,000 miles but change oil filters every 3000-5000 miles. Guess that has all changed.

SHAME ON THE VW DIESEL SOFTWARE PROGRAMMERS.
I have owned (4)VW's over the last 50 years but after this mess, I have my doubts if we will every own another. I have lost all confidence in VW vehicles especially diesels.

RLK
2012 TOYOTA PRIUS
2008 TOYOTA PRIUS
 
I just washed my factory GM cabin filter out and it's as good as new. No carbon in it. The replacement is $20 locally, Amazon is only $9. Washing is free. The carbon thing is a gimmick. There is not enough carbon in them to do anything after a day or two. Activated carbon wears out and has to be thick enough to filter odors. Wouldn't surprise me if the manufactures put a little clean smell in just to make people think they work. We have carbon air filters at work and they are a foot thick and have to be changed a lot.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom