I'm dragging this up to post what is a positive development.
I kept my eyes open, and something did indeed materialize at another school in the area-a tenure track professor of chemistry position. I applied, and was contacted a few days later(before the application closed) asking to come in for an interview with a couple of times available.
I went in on March 2nd for an interview with the search committee that ended up being 2 1/2 hours including a tour of their facilities(not scheduled, but offered and of course I accepted). I walked out feeling GREAT about the position.
Of course, a lot has happened in the world in the time since the interview, but none the less I was also called for follow-up Skype interview a week and a half ago with one of the deans who wasn't able to be present at the original panel interview.
That was followed last Thursday with an offer, which after a bit of negotiation I accepted today.
Salary wise, it's more or less a lateral move but professionally puts me in a good spot with a lot of opportunity to grow and a lot of good non-monetary perks. Plus, I'll finally be in the same area code as my fiancé.
The new position doesn't start until August, which fortunately also gives me plenty of time to wrap up a bunch of loose ends at my current job and get moved(as a bit of a pack rat, the last one is more daunting that it should be).
I've had a great 5 years at my current employer, and I'll be(mostly) sorry to go. Evidently they will be as well, as they did put together a salary offer to try and keep me(part of what took me close to a week to accept the new position). It was a respectable offer, but not enough to outweigh some other factors that went into the decision. I feel good about the decision, and so does my fiancé, but it wasn't easy. None the less, this feels more right than any other opportunity I've pursued.