Coupla years ago I asked three engineers who work for filter manufacturers what the shelf life of a filter might be. From two I got PC answers, since our discussion was on the record. Basically, it boiled down to 3 years, with one hedging that 5 might be OK. Another, who was in a position where he didn't need to be PC, said 8 years or more. He went on to say the shelf life of a filter stored in a clean, temperature and moisture stable environment is quite long. He said if you don't see signs of moisture, you are likely good to go. Excess moisture can be harmful to cellulose media and that's something you really can't check. The signs of moisture, he said, was rust on the tapping plate. He said that was the sign he personally used to decide the risk of an old filter. The more rust he saw, the higher the risk. I think many older filters would be perfectly fine and there is anecdotal instances of people using REALLY old stuff (like WWII surplus) and having no problem. You have to gauge your willingness to take a risk based on the age of the filter. THe soft parts and glues of the filter are probably subject to aging as well but I didn't get into detail on those elements with the three engineers. With no signs of moisture evident, I wouldn't be afraid to use '03 or '04 filters personally but I also prefer to use the latest and best filter technology, not 10 year old tech.