Originally Posted By: Ed_T
With 12.5 compression ratio they work quite hard, with the computer always trying to lug the engine as best it can under constantly changing loading. I change oil at the 5k mile mark, and it comes out looking pretty well used. No analysis done to date.
Ahhhhooooghhhhaaa!!! Ding! Ding! Ding!!!
(Speaking gently here... )Actually, Ed... that's not correct. The Atkinson engine in the HyCam, at least, has an EXPANSION RATIO of 12.5:1. I got confused on this myself.... I think you have to look at these engines as close relatives of steam engines. The compression ratio hovers (apologies Pilot!)around 10:1, about 80% of the expansion stroke for the reasons AH64Pilot stated. But it could be a lot lower under some conditions where the engine is lightly loaded, e.g., battery charging when sitting; or, greater, when you've got your foot in it for full power acceleration.
IMO, "hovers" is the right term as I think the CR varies within a predetermined range depending on engine loading and driver demands, always seeking the optimum operating regime for lowest emissions, highest mpg, and best performance under all conditions.
I'd agree that they are low rpm engines but I'm certain they do not 'lug.' "Lugging" is usually associated with wide throttle settings and too tall a gear selection for the vehicle speed. I'm not sure it's possible in a hybrid as 'synergy drive' system is similar to a continuously variable gear box. The SDS' computer
will not let the internal combustion engine (ICE) get into an operating envelope where it will lug. IME, the dang ICE has a mind of its own and the driver really doesn't have direct control over its operation so you couldn't 'lug' it even if you wanted. For example...
Pressing on the gas when in Park or Neutral will NOT raise the ICE's rpm.
Pressing on the gas in Drive with the brake on will not raise the rpm.
The ICE will rev higher to charge battery anytime it needs (wants?)to. You can't control it.
At speeds over 40, the ICE operates at a low level to stay hot and 'armed' for higher speeds should you need it. You can be at 65 mph and have the ICE at idle ... or it may, depending on conditions rev higher. It just goes up and down depending on demands. Resistance is few-tile!!
In agreement with AH64Pilot in that you're essentially driving an electric car that is augmented by a high efficiency, modest output, Atkinson cycle ICE. As such, they really don't work that hard.
I, for one, I'd be interested in an oil analysis if you do one, Ed. Oil does get black and nasty in a short time but that's a good thing. Its supposed to do that...
Cheers!
[color:#33CC00][/color]