Yikes. This is the worst tearing filter I’ve seen. Also, I think pointing to the filter being run over 5k miles as the cause of the tears is an error. I understand that it’s rated at 5k miles, but they’re (NAPA) recommending the filter for vehicles with manufacturer recommended OCIs which supersede 5k miles. For instance, the 27002 is recommended for the Mazda 2.5l which has an OCI of between 5k and 10k miles depending on MY. If a company is going to recommend the filter, it should be able to withstand all possible durations of OCI.
Thanks for the post OP.