I was going to link the same. You might need to hunt but they also have shipping options. I bought a white matched fender for my daughters '08 CRV. I drove to CT to pick it up to keep any shipping issues away.https://www.car-part.com/
If this is a popular model, you might be able to find a color match, especially being in a populous state like NJ. Some yards can source from adjacent states too.
Getting a bumper in mint condition from a yard might be a challenge. In the body industry, there is typically "clean-up" time to fix any imperfections. If it's the wrong color, a body shop will have to sand/repair at least the front face because fresh paint will amplify even light stone chips.
Just make sure the recycled one is not aftermarket, they typically have a yellow capa sticker on the inside face if it's a higher grade AM. Low grade AM, you can't tell until you install it, that is it might not fit perfectly.
You'll need an absorber as well and make sure the reinforcement beam isn't bent either, not likely by the picture but worth checking.
What year make model?
I just bought 2 CV axles for my son's '10 Forte with 87k on them. His drivers side went and Kia has discontinued them.
Co-worker got a matching blue fender for his Civic Si from Car-part also.