Fram Extended Guard: Come right out and say it.

[Cristobal]

I decided to add one of these to my filter stash. It was $8.97 at Walmart I recall.

I know it is a good filter, but how well does it cut it compared with the best ones from Bosch (such as the Distance Plus) and Mobil for extended OCI's?

I know these latter brands can be cheaper on a sale/refund basis, so price is not the main subject of my inquiry. But if you do not want to do the refund thing, you still save on postage a wee bit and the price is OK, cash on the barrel head.

 

[Knox]

It's a good filter, i'd say on the same level as a Bosch distance plus or Mobil extended.

The only down side i can think of, if any, is that the bypass valve is made of plastic with a coil spring. Technically that should seal better then metal alone though.

 

[ZeeOSix]

XG is a decent filter ... only Fram I'd use.

 

[mobilaltima]

i just put a 9837 fram XG on my buddies 3.7 colorado and some 5W30 Penn. Platinum, hes gonna run 6k ocis, no worries.

 

[yaris0128]

If it wasnt so expenisve Id use them but I know a SuperTech or Purolator will work just fine for a lot less cash.

 

[Indydriver]

I used all varieties of Fram filters in my 3000 mile OCI Dino days. I guess I can admit that peer pressure here at BITOG has pushed me to syn, extended OCIs and P1 filters. I'm still waiting for someone to prove that Fram=junk. My only observation about your post is that I would never pay $9 for any oil filter. With all the deals around, you can easily get your buy price <$5.

 

[pzev]

Extended Guard is a good filter. Two ply media (it is actually two plies, I cut one open and pulled them apart. Posted the video on here some months back), with metal mesh backing. Filter can is very durable, and while plastic, the bypass has a nice sturdy coil spring and fits well into the housing.
Nothing wrong with these filters at all, and they aren't that bad of a deal @ $9 either, considering the durability of the media and whatnot. This all depends on whether or not you're comfortable running the filter for a long OCI...something its certainly capable of. This would certainly change the price metric a bit...
I've cut open just about every major filter brand in my cars size (3614), and I'd put the Extended Guard near the top for sure.

 

[kemo]

I won't use it, simply because of the bypass valve. Plastic? no thanks!