Am I wrong in this situation ?
About a year ago Pep Boys paper and online ad shows Peak Professional Lifetime antifreeze concentrate at $2-3 a gallon after $7-8 per gallon mail in rebate, limit 2 gallons. I bought 2 gallons online with local pickup, I print the receipt and took it to the store. I showed it to the cashier, she told me to go to the antifreeze shell to pickup 2 gallons, when she rang it up it shows the full price of $27-28 a gallon, not the sale price of $9-10 a gallon. She then told me the sale price was actually the Peak all-makes not the Professional Lifetime, the picture and the descriptions on the ad was wrong, the part number is the all-makes.
I said no-way, I had no idea what part number for which antifreeze, all I know was the picture and the description clearly showed the Professional Lifetime, I asked to speak to the store manager to see what he can do to correct the problem, I said to the cashier that I didn't drive 20 miles round trip for nothing.
The store manager first said it was an error in the ad from the corporate, nothing he could do. I told him that "Fault Advertising" is against the law, if the ad clearly indicate the sale price of a product they have to honor the price, otherwise I will complaint to the county/state DA, BBB and other agencies. He then instructed the cashier to enter the code of 2 gallons all-make but let me take the 2 gallons Professional Lifetime and the mail in rebate coupon.
Looking back, I think their ad was an error because there is no way they can discount a regular product more than 50% and still make a profit.
If you know the price and/or the product in the ad, print ad or online, is an error do you still demand the store sells it to you at that price, before they have a chance to correct the error ?
PS I wasn't angry or raised voice when talking to either cashier of store manager, I just asking for the 2 gallons Peak Professional Lifetime at the price on the order form I print from online with a firm voice.