Bimmerpost says no to 0w40 but not here?

I'd say 0W-40 is a step-up from 5W-30.
I started using 0 40 after GM disaster I looked into it seems they’ve been using it in Europe for quite some time. The reason not so much here in the US is because of the EPA standards with MPG and the government’s ratings that have to be met. I live in a cold climate so zero would be great. I’ll have to see if there’s a difference in gas mileage cause I really really keep an eye on it only because to see if there’s an issue with my ignition system. I guess we’ll see.
 
It might have to do with at least some years of the B58 having a plastic oil pump housing. With high viscosity oil under certain conditions the plastic housing would crack. That's what I remember at least.
Are you due it wasn’t that the drive gear shears off?
 
It might have to do with at least some years of the B58 having a plastic oil pump housing. With high viscosity oil under certain conditions the plastic housing would crack. That's what I remember at least.
FCP Euro made a statement to that effect and iirc their statement suggested the information came from BMW
 
It might have to do with at least some years of the B58 having a plastic oil pump housing. With high viscosity oil under certain conditions the plastic housing would crack. That's what I remember at least.
It is pump. Period.
It is happening with strictly dealership maintained vehicles. I think they changed pump back to previous version around 2022.
 
It might have to do with at least some years of the B58 having a plastic oil pump housing. With high viscosity oil under certain conditions the plastic housing would crack. That's what I remember at least.
There’s no proof other than an assertion from some dude that works at FCPEuro. If it were accurate then the pump would be failing in Canada at 10x the rate in Florida. We have no evidence it’s true or viscosity related.
 
It might have to do with at least some years of the B58 having a plastic oil pump housing. With high viscosity oil under certain conditions the plastic housing would crack. That's what I remember at least.
Shouldn't be an issue in OP's 2022.

To OP, although the USA manual only shows LL17FE, anything with the LL17FE, LL04, LL01/LL01FE approvals is going to be fine per BMW's official service manual. Don't overthink this stuff, just use whatever's most available.

And if you are worried about 0w20, I wouldn't be. These cars have a very impressive thermal management system that, per my own observation, runs the oil reasonably cool as a baseline and dips the oil temperature very quickly and holds it there if it thinks you're driving it hard. They clearly didn't just throw the 0w-20 sticker on there without putting some engineering into it.

This is as opposed to the N series engines that tend to run the oil hot-ish as a baseline and use a simple thermostatic valve for the oil cooler. 5w40 in those bad boys all day.
 
I have a Gen 2 B58 looking for 0w30 or 5w30 located in Vegas. I see 0w40 being recommended here but it's not recommended in bimmerpost.

For example: https://g20.bimmerpost.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2230344

Any idea why that is? Also is Castrol EDGE Euro 5w30 A3/B4 fine to use on a 2022 b58?
There’s no point in a 0w might as well stick with a 5w30 or 5w40. Quaker State Euro / Pennzoil Platinum Euro / Red Line 5w30 white bottle / Amsoil Signature Series /or Molygen all work well. I find it likes the heavier oils. If doing shorter OCI (not 15k or anything) I really like Molygen. Red Line held up great after a long road trip and beating on it excessively hard in Moab at 105F (Grenadier) I just hate the bottles. The Molygen stack perfectly in my slide out drawers and are easy to work with. I do 5k OCI though as I’m driving 6000lbs with much heavier tires and tuned. I don’t have it in me to run a 0w20 at all.
 
Last edited:
There’s no point in a 0w might as well stick with a 5w30 or 5w40. Quaker State Euro / Pennzoil Platinum Euro / Red Line 5w30 white bottle / Amsoil Signature Series /or Molygen all work well. I find it likes the heavier oils. If doing shorter OCI (not 15k or anything) I really like Molygen. Red Line held up great after a long road trip and beating on it excessively hard in Moab at 105F (Grenadier) I just hate the bottles. The Molygen stack perfectly in my slide out drawers and are easy to work with. I do 5k OCI though as I’m driving 6000lbs with much heavier tires and tuned. I don’t have it in me to run a 0w20 at all.
Why not a 0 winter? 0W-40 is just fine here.
 
Back
Top Bottom