I agree-- Those just weren't VW years for reliability. I purchased an 01 VW a few years back, owned it for two years and took about a 4k loss to get out of it.
Steering rack went, tensioner bearing, some interior stuff, driver window fell into door, every week this thing had a new problem. That's not to mention the half dozen recalls in that period of time, of which the brake light switch was one of them. I even had a recall for the heated seats catching fire! I wonder how many people got their asses burnt before they figured that one out?
GREAT looking and fun to drive cars though, just not worth the hassle.