As others have mentioned the '99 > 2002 FORD Escort w/5 speed manual , CHEVY Prizm '99 > 2002 w/5 speed , and COROLLA '99 > 2005 w/ 5 speed be good choices . Also may want to consider an TOYOTA Echo , SCION XA , or XB w/ 5 speed manual . That's if you can get past the toaster on wheels look . All these will likely exceed 35 m.p.g.. Most should be under $5,000 . If possible , take your time to get as much info ( records ) and background ( flood , etc. ) on the car of your choice . Good luck and let us know on your decision and how it works out for you .