I tried loosening with my hands first. Standing over the filter looking down, the direction to remove the filter is turning the ratchet clockwise. To eliminate all confusion, I always make sure the selector on the ratchet is in the correct position and verify by trying to turn the socket by hand. Zero chance of operator error that way.If you installed the oil filter handtight, you can remove the oil filter without the oil filter wrench. With the wrench it's even easier without any effort at all. I have a strong feeling you removed it on the opposite direction>>righty tighty