Now you know if he told you he'd have to kill you

.... its proprietary.
I actually followed your arguments and I feel similar but I dont fight it out here anymore because its pointless.
if it blows up after 10k miles it was dodge jeep ram Chrysler quality.. if it lasts until sold it was great. etc.
I am very particular about transmission fluids I still dont understand why subaru would need 5 and stock 5..
when one aftermarket covers 4 of those 5 and replaces 30 other specs too.
(not talking about amsoil in particular just multi vehicle/universal type atf replacement options)
Wouldnt a manufacturer want to spec and stock 1 or 2 vs 5?