Originally Posted By: Danh
Originally Posted By: WhizkidTN
Originally Posted By: Danh
No easy answer to this question, but a few thoughts:
1) The "nose test" may or may not be reliable given individual sensitivity. A oil analysis is the only reliable way to reach a conclusion.
2) If fuel dilution is your concern, forget about Blackstone as its methodology is deeply flawed: try Oil Analyzers, which uses gas chromotography, instead. I believe you can get a single test kit through Amsoil.
3) A consequence is fuel dilution is reduced oil viscosity. Dilution of 5% (which isn't that uncommon in DI engines) can reduce viscosity by one full grade. So whether you test or not, consider moving to a 5w30 or 5w-40 as allowed by Hyundai.
4) My DI Honda is a fuel diluter and my experience is dilution occurs pretty quickly but then stabilizes, albeit at an uncomfortably high level. Highway driving doesn't seem to really "burn off" excess fuel as one would expect. So, short of changing oil every 1,000 miles, there doesn't seem to be a perfect solution.
5) If you do have fuel dilution, some have found using 91/93 octane fuel helps.
So, if you don't want to go the used oil analysis route, I'd suggest going up a grade or two in viscosity with an oil change interval of 4-5 months, 4-5,000 miles. My Honda doesn't allow a viscosity other than 0w-20 for warranty, so I'm on a 4 month/4,000 mile regimen.
I'd encourage you to invest the $30 or so for a used oil analysis from Oil Analyzers. You may not have a problem, but if you do you'll at least know its extent.
Good luck!
I think this is excellent advise. I just today got back my used oil analysis from both BlackStone and OilAnalyzers for a sample I just ran in my 2.0T Optima (3.8K mile on the sample). I'll post it up later but there is a BIG difference between these two on the fuel dilution issue. I drove mine ~17 miles on the highway before changing it to get a good and hot sample. I run Costco/Shell 93 octane gas (it is my DD), have an Oil Catch Can (a very good one) and run Mobil 1 0W-40 oil with OCI of ~4K miles. Not much else to do about it. Car runs GREAT, never uses oil.
It would be much appreciated if you were to post these used oil analysis. But as a guess, is the OilAnalyzers' fuel dilution 3-4 percentage points higher than Blackstone's?
Yup, I'm planning on doing that soon. I need to edit out the personal info first (having some minor computer problems at the moment).
Just for a "teaser", the Blackstone report & comments say fuel dilution is at "0.55 - GC" and Oxidation (they considered it severe) at 34 abs/cm. That was the reason I did a dual report, to check them against each other.