I liked the previous Gen Civics enough to go and look when the new ones came out (06?). I did not like the hand brake location, and it was too small in general.
I got an Acura RSX Base 5m instead. It was roomier, drove great. Maybe more power in base form. MPG topped at 27-29, not too great. I thought the simplicity of the older design would lead to reliable owner experience, but build from Japan was poor. A lot of probs with the windshield. The car was delivered with it loose, dealer failed to fix it and scraped my a-pillar in the process on a week-old car. Seat bottom crushed, trim fell off that I had to fix properly. 45k miles and I was never happy with that car, not for a day.
Anyway, I should have got the Accord Coupe instead of the RSX in 06 but got an 07 Accord later, with a decent discount for it being the outgoing model.
The Accord 2.4 automatic gets the same mpg as the RSX 2.0 5-speed, but much roomier and more power. It has the cool styling of the Civic Coupe, but much less of what I feel are shortcomings of the Civic (for me) like the ebrake and driver comfort. I know the mpg of the Civic is good though. Maybe better real-world mpg than all non-hybrids.