15 hours of driving through the snowstorm.

Joined
Jul 29, 2005
Messages
3,355
Location
Diesel Central, Indiana
We headed North for Thanksgiving. We took our trusty 2011 GX460 with Michelin Defender MS2 tires (265/70r18).

The return trip yesterday saw us leaving Red Wing MN at 0800 local and arriving 0030 back home again in Indiana šŸŽ¶ (Columbus, 45 min south of Indy). That's 15.5 hours (with stops) of driving in nearly endless snow and wind.

We went by way of Warsaw, IN, since Daughter is a college student there.

Only when we got to Westfield on the north side of Indianapolis did the turn to rain/wet instead of snow. That was somewhere around hour 14 of the trip.

It was snowing in Red Wing when we left. Snowing when we saw the bald eagles cruising along the Mississippi River on the MN side. Snowing in LaCrosse. Snowing in Madison. Snowing in Rockford. And Chicago. And Merrilville. And Warsaw. All the way to just north of Indianapolis.

Some observations from the experience:

  • HPL 15w-40 cranks just fine in 20F ambient cold start. Nearly instant oil pressure in the 1UR-FE.
  • Despite my skepticism of long-wearing tires, the Defender MS2s were quite the performers in the snow and wet. The tires have 12k miles on them and appear new with nice deep tread. The siping grabs snow and holds it and makes it very effective.
    • Foot deep snow freshly fallen? Not a problem.With AWD distributing the work, the Defenders made it child's play to get around every unplowed parking lot and side street we encountered.
    • The only limit to the depth of snow that this combination can pass is the ground clearance. Once you're plowing with the skid plates, you will likely lose traction. But not until then. A foot of snow is no problem, I think you'd get into issues around 15"-18" potentially.
    • The allocation of credit for tires vs AWD has to strongly favor the tires. AWD will not let you stop any faster at all and the braking traction in all manner of snow was superb. Not to mention that even somewhat spritely acceleration did not engage the traction control.
  • The GX/Defender combo was able to pass slower cars by using the unplowed passing lane at 50+mph. Over the course of the return trip, this likely saved several hours vs plodding along at 15mph-25mph in the sole plowed lane available and clogged by slow traffic. That time savings was the difference between completing the trip in one day vs having to scramble to find a hotel. That's the difference between exhausted but home in your own bed vs exhausted, in a mystery motel bed, and rising only to face hours more travel in bad conditions.
  • TWICE we personally witnessed a car spin out of control right in front of us. One made an impressive recovery after a couple 360s and thankfully no contact to us or other vehicles. The other ended up backwards in a ditch with likely little to no damage. It's sort of amazing how people can be living somewhere with regular heavy snow every year and still not grasp concepts like transitions of snow depth will induce vehicle yaw. Stay in the two tracks and don't change lanes more than absolutely necessary while doing so very slowly and with laser focus on steering wheel control. The number of ditched and wrecked vehicles as well as jackknifed trucks was more than I could bother to count. It is only by the grace of God that we were not involved as a bystander casualty in some of these accidents.
Past experience with the GX on Defenders was similarly confidence-inspiring. Only on black ice did it falter, but then again, anything short of studded winter tires would fail also.

The Defenders handled the transition to water/rain quite well, Many tires that do well in snow are poor in rain and vice versa. The Defenders have a very good balance.

The GX is a trusted family friend at this point-- a battle-tested tank of an unstoppable bad weather beast of burden. It's not a perfect vehicle, but the capability in bad weather and marginal conditions is elite-level. In deep snow, it's actually better than a dual locker setup because the Toyota system can bias torque dynamically from 0% to 100% left to right and up to 80/20 front to rear. A fully locked setup is 50/50 front to rear and 50/50 L/R, giving 25% per tire under all conditions. The GX's Torsen Type C center can route up to 80% power to either front or rear, dynamically adjusting both torque differences as well as the the direction of torque application (forward vs reverse). And since the ATRAC/TRAC system can actually lock out a zero traction wheel, the system can apply up to 80% of available torque to any single wheel. That's elite performance.

I never thought to lock the center differential yesterday. It never even came to mind. The open Torsen just was a brilliant mastermind of torque routing under all conditions.

Glad to be home safe and sound. The GX on Defenders was nigh unstoppable, and it's earned a bit of R&R this week.
 
Good write up.

When driving in ruts, I like to "mean it" when I change lanes and try to get it done in about 4-5 seconds. Too much time out of the ruts invites problems. Not jerking the wheel meaning it, but moving with intent.

No pictures? 😁
 
Glad you made it home safely. We were in Madison this past week, but opted to head for warmer weather on Friday instead of Saturday, even though I had put winter tires on the Pilot (Conti VC8s). We got well south of the winter weather dividing line before stopping for the night. Normally it's an 18 hour trip straight through, stopping only for gas and potty breaks. Having left mid-morning, we chose to get a room and finish the trip yesterday.

Last year on our way home from Thanksgiving in Madison, we drove through the type conditions you've described from about 50 miles north of Kansas City to south of Topeka. We had the Audi Q5 with the OEM Continental all season tires. This year with the new Pilot, I told the wife we weren't making the trip without winter tires.
 
Drove through a few nasty hours of snow…..BF Goodrich tires on our truck did very well.

Glad you got home safe!!!
 
I been driving on Nokians All Weather tires with great success on ice and snow the last ten years or so, but I want to try the Michelin Cross Climates next go around on our Jeep Grand Cherokee. Many people do not realize the difference in tires for driving on ice and snow, sometimes a little extra money spent save a lot of headaches down the road, and even possibly lives. Another thing is to make sure you have adequate tread depth for ice and snow; too many people wear the tire tread down too far for safe traveling. Have a safe holiday season everyone.
 
Hohn shared:
It's sort of amazing how people can be living somewhere with regular heavy snow every year and still not grasp concepts like transitions of snow depth will induce vehicle yaw. Stay in the two tracks and don't change lanes more than absolutely necessary while doing so very slowly and with laser focus on steering wheel control. The number of ditched and wrecked vehicles as well as jackknifed trucks was more than I could bother to count.

Many people are idiots. Slowing down to meet the weather/vehicle conditions is the main ingredient to success in snow.
 
Agree, but good winter/ all-weather tires can save people from looking like total idiots at times.
I agree with you. In the transition areas like southern Michigan, Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, southern Wisconsin, etc., people tend not to outfit their vehicles with special winter tires, but instead run all seasons. People here rely on the roads getting heavily salted and refuse to leave early to work, slow down, leave extra between-vehicle space, etc.. No inconveniences allowed. Under these circumstances, slowing down is the key ingredient to success. Every year, over and over, first snowfall(s) equals tons of accidents. Yes, I'm a cynical, almost old curmudgeon. ;)
 
We headed North for Thanksgiving. We took our trusty 2011 GX460 with Michelin Defender MS2 tires (265/70r18).

The return trip yesterday saw us leaving Red Wing MN at 0800 local and arriving 0030 back home again in Indiana šŸŽ¶ (Columbus, 45 min south of Indy). That's 15.5 hours (with stops) of driving in nearly endless snow and wind.

We went by way of Warsaw, IN, since Daughter is a college student there.

Only when we got to Westfield on the north side of Indianapolis did the turn to rain/wet instead of snow. That was somewhere around hour 14 of the trip.

It was snowing in Red Wing when we left. Snowing when we saw the bald eagles cruising along the Mississippi River on the MN side. Snowing in LaCrosse. Snowing in Madison. Snowing in Rockford. And Chicago. And Merrilville. And Warsaw. All the way to just north of Indianapolis.

Some observations from the experience:

  • HPL 15w-40 cranks just fine in 20F ambient cold start. Nearly instant oil pressure in the 1UR-FE.
  • Despite my skepticism of long-wearing tires, the Defender MS2s were quite the performers in the snow and wet. The tires have 12k miles on them and appear new with nice deep tread. The siping grabs snow and holds it and makes it very effective.
    • Foot deep snow freshly fallen? Not a problem.With AWD distributing the work, the Defenders made it child's play to get around every unplowed parking lot and side street we encountered.
    • The only limit to the depth of snow that this combination can pass is the ground clearance. Once you're plowing with the skid plates, you will likely lose traction. But not until then. A foot of snow is no problem, I think you'd get into issues around 15"-18" potentially.
    • The allocation of credit for tires vs AWD has to strongly favor the tires. AWD will not let you stop any faster at all and the braking traction in all manner of snow was superb. Not to mention that even somewhat spritely acceleration did not engage the traction control.
  • The GX/Defender combo was able to pass slower cars by using the unplowed passing lane at 50+mph. Over the course of the return trip, this likely saved several hours vs plodding along at 15mph-25mph in the sole plowed lane available and clogged by slow traffic. That time savings was the difference between completing the trip in one day vs having to scramble to find a hotel. That's the difference between exhausted but home in your own bed vs exhausted, in a mystery motel bed, and rising only to face hours more travel in bad conditions.
  • TWICE we personally witnessed a car spin out of control right in front of us. One made an impressive recovery after a couple 360s and thankfully no contact to us or other vehicles. The other ended up backwards in a ditch with likely little to no damage. It's sort of amazing how people can be living somewhere with regular heavy snow every year and still not grasp concepts like transitions of snow depth will induce vehicle yaw. Stay in the two tracks and don't change lanes more than absolutely necessary while doing so very slowly and with laser focus on steering wheel control. The number of ditched and wrecked vehicles as well as jackknifed trucks was more than I could bother to count. It is only by the grace of God that we were not involved as a bystander casualty in some of these accidents.
Past experience with the GX on Defenders was similarly confidence-inspiring. Only on black ice did it falter, but then again, anything short of studded winter tires would fail also.

The Defenders handled the transition to water/rain quite well, Many tires that do well in snow are poor in rain and vice versa. The Defenders have a very good balance.

The GX is a trusted family friend at this point-- a battle-tested tank of an unstoppable bad weather beast of burden. It's not a perfect vehicle, but the capability in bad weather and marginal conditions is elite-level. In deep snow, it's actually better than a dual locker setup because the Toyota system can bias torque dynamically from 0% to 100% left to right and up to 80/20 front to rear. A fully locked setup is 50/50 front to rear and 50/50 L/R, giving 25% per tire under all conditions. The GX's Torsen Type C center can route up to 80% power to either front or rear, dynamically adjusting both torque differences as well as the the direction of torque application (forward vs reverse). And since the ATRAC/TRAC system can actually lock out a zero traction wheel, the system can apply up to 80% of available torque to any single wheel. That's elite performance.

I never thought to lock the center differential yesterday. It never even came to mind. The open Torsen just was a brilliant mastermind of torque routing under all conditions.

Glad to be home safe and sound. The GX on Defenders was nigh unstoppable, and it's earned a bit of R&R this week.
Thanksgiving Iron man award!
 
Great write up!

I’ve run several sets of the Michelin LTX M/S 2 and Defender LTX.

I like the fact that the sipes are full-depth. Most brands don’t have full-depth siping, so, after a certain level of treadwear, you no longer have sipes.

Unfortunately, the sipes on the new continental Tour 54’s on our van are not full depth.
 
Good write up.

When driving in ruts, I like to "mean it" when I change lanes and try to get it done in about 4-5 seconds. Too much time out of the ruts invites problems. Not jerking the wheel meaning it, but moving with intent.

No pictures? 😁
Changing lanes too quickly is how the two spinouts I witness occurred. Too high of a yaw rate was induced, and just a kiss of deeper snow was enough to send them spinning.

I prefer to change lanes slowly but counteract the yaw induced by hitting deeper snow. You have to steer away from it since it will try to pull you in.

I have a short video clip, that's it.
 
TWICE we personally witnessed a car spin out of control right in front of us
Number of years ago I was trying to beat a snowstorm home. Timed it wrong... was cooking along on top of however much snow was on the road (all white, at least an inch), started wondering if it was time to slow down. Watched an Exploder do a 360 in front me. Decided that was my sign that the roads were getting slippery.

[Another time I watched an SUV do a 360 in front of me--after a summer's rain. I guess tread isn't just there for passing inspection. Given how he pulled that off at 35mph after the rain had stopped... it might have been more cords than rubber. Tires, they're kinda important.]
 
I agree with you. In the transition areas like southern Michigan, Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, southern Wisconsin, etc., people tend not to outfit their vehicles with special winter tires, but instead run all seasons. People here rely on the roads getting heavily salted and refuse to leave early to work, slow down, leave extra between-vehicle space, etc.. No inconveniences allowed. Under these circumstances, slowing down is the key ingredient to success. Every year, over and over, first snowfall(s) equals tons of accidents. Yes, I'm a cynical, almost old curmudgeon. ;)

Yep, saw that today…..
 
Nice writeup. But likley preaching to the choir.

Most who read post on BITOG are way above the ones using bald tires in bad conditions when it comes to vehicle maintance.

Every year it's a repeat of the same old same old, people without background learning the hardway. Wish it weren't so, but some can't learn by words alone.

Personally, I would avoid traveling in any snow-storm if at all possible. I can drive in snow. But no one can drive in a white-out. Because of that, I avoid highway travel if it's going to snow. White-outs are rare but they are terable. Been there, done that, never wana be there again.
 
I been driving on Nokians All Weather tires with great success on ice and snow the last ten years or so, but I want to try the Michelin Cross Climates next go around on our Jeep Grand Cherokee. Many people do not realize the difference in tires for driving on ice and snow, sometimes a little extra money spent save a lot of headaches down the road, and even possibly lives. Another thing is to make sure you have adequate tread depth for ice and snow; too many people wear the tire tread down too far for safe traveling. Have a safe holiday season everyone.

Nokien are the king of winter tires, only thing that’s better is studded winter tires and chains

The new Nokian Outpostā„¢ nAT are the bees knees for SUV tires
 
Nice writeup. But likley preaching to the choir.

Most who read post on BITOG are way above the ones using bald tires in bad conditions when it comes to vehicle maintance.

Every year it's a repeat of the same old same old, people without background learning the hardway. Wish it weren't so, but some can't learn by words alone.

Personally, I would avoid traveling in any snow-storm if at all possible. I can drive in snow. But no one can drive in a white-out. Because of that, I avoid highway travel if it's going to snow. White-outs are rare but they are terable. Been there, done that, never wana be there again.
Whiteouts are bad, BAD news. I got caught in one that popped up out of nowhere halfway between Anchorage and Fairbanks in my trusty steed, my M819 recovery vehicle. I was "Tail end charlie" in the convoy headed to Fairbanks (in case any of the other trucks broke down). Even though it was a bright day, there was so much snow blowing that the wipers couldnt even BEGIN to clear the windshield. I had to crawl along with the window down so I could look down past the running boards to catch a glimpse of the road. Darn near froze my keister off. Stopping, even though I had my sleeping bag and a crate of c-rats on the truck would have been a very bad idea, temperature being what it was. It took me a hour or so to catch up with the rest of the convoy where they had to stop to hole up until the storm abated. They kept in touch with me via cb while waiting for me to trundle out of that storm. All I could tell them was that I was still moving. THAT was a white knuckle experience! We were stuck there for 2 days. I do NOT want to think about what would have happened if I had gone off the road and been stuck in that storm for 2 days. NOPE!
 
Last edited:
Nokien are the king of winter tires, only thing that’s better is studded winter tires and chains

The new Nokian Outpostā„¢ nAT are the bees knees for SUV tires
I have the Outpost nAT on my Silverado. Got them installed a few months ago. Hoping for some good snow this winter to test them out.
 
I really wanted some Nokian nAT for the GX based on my very good experience with the WRGs on my commuter beater. But the distribution locally is poor and I simply couldn’t get them. Discount is the only place to get Nokians here and they said they couldn’t tell me when they would have any. Also, the NATs didn’t offer them i 265/70r18.

So I ended up with Defender MS2s, which fit our usage superbly. They’re basically highway tires with excellent wet and snow traction and ā€œgood enoughā€ on marginal offroad surfaces if you have the good sense to avoid deep mud and sand. On two tracks, gravel, rock, etc they are more than adequate while keeping amazing manners on road in terms of noise, ride, and MPG.
 
Back
Top Bottom