I think a lot of places have prorated warranties on batteries. I don't have a problem with it.Wow. Never heard of such a thing on a battery. What turds. I've had batteries die before the end the warranty and just went back to the store with my receipt and the core, grabbed a new one, paid any difference between the price and walked out 5 min later. That difference might be $10-15 but not like what Costco is trying to pull. Screw that.
In fact, this is why you cannot go wrong with the Everstart Platinum for $180. Save your receipt, party like a rock star and if it wont put out anymore, turn it back in before it turns 4 years old.