Originally Posted By: Pop_Rivit
But the fact remains it's nothing more than a computer program, with no real heart and soul. Just because a few fools in Japan and elsewhere fawn over a fake computer image still doesn't make it real, no matter how much they want it to be. It will never draw it's inspiration from the audience, it's performance will be exactly the same time and time again, and it will never need to practice in order to perfect that slight nuance that seems to elude it. The heart of it's music is nothing more than a computer program, and it will never be able to put it a lifetime of human experience into what it passes off as music.
A real performer pours their heart and soul into their music. They don't rely on computers, fakery or electronic gizmos for their talent. Their talent is the result of hard work, years of dedication, practice, and a love for the music. A real performer draws energy from the audience, and uses that energy to improve their own performance, something your cartoon character can never do.
I don't know if the OP's virtual "musician" could ever perform live. Don't know how much it would deviate from the virtual sound. But virtual bands like
Dethklok and
Gorrilaz do perform live.
The personalities of the virtual band are sometimes so over the top and storied that they can enhance the overall listening experience. In a way, it's not all that different than '70s rock operas like
Tommy, The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars, The Wall, or Joe's Garage. (no, I'm not comparing Gorillaz or Dethklok to The Who, Pink Floyd, etc... just saying that it gives the songs a back story. I'm a fan of Metalocalypse and Gorillaz obviously but it is not on the level of Pink Floyd or The Who)