What happens to the butter you baste your turkey with?

Joined
Aug 5, 2002
Messages
24,498
Location
Silicon Valley
Let's say deep frying is not going to happen (I know it is good, I just don't want to deep fry something that big). Let's also say you don't cut your turkey and roast / bake the breast and legs separately. You are most likely going to baste it with butter under the skin / on the breast, and tent it to avoid drying out, right?

So, I've seen people using cheesecloth to keep the turkey moist by self basting / pulling the juice back to the turkey, or use like 1lb of butter to baste it initially. Either way you end up with a lot of butter + turkey fat at the bottom of the pan. Do you use that dripping to make gravy? or refrigerate to remove the grease but keep the gel / juice for stock? Is there a way to baste a turkey without using butter? (I don't like the smell of too much butter on turkey, and that might be one of the reason I am not always a fan of thanksgiving turkey but ok with deli turkey)
 
Gravy, you betcha.

Carcass gets boiled down afterwards with onions/celery, strained, lots of broth for future use.
 
Let's say deep frying is not going to happen (I know it is good, I just don't want to deep fry something that big). Let's also say you don't cut your turkey and roast / bake the breast and legs separately. You are most likely going to baste it with butter under the skin / on the breast, and tent it to avoid drying out, right?

So, I've seen people using cheesecloth to keep the turkey moist by self basting / pulling the juice back to the turkey, or use like 1lb of butter to baste it initially. Either way you end up with a lot of butter + turkey fat at the bottom of the pan. Do you use that dripping to make gravy? or refrigerate to remove the grease but keep the gel / juice for stock? Is there a way to baste a turkey without using butter? (I don't like the smell of too much butter on turkey, and that might be one of the reason I am not always a fan of thanksgiving turkey but ok with deli turkey)
You can go the water, apple juice/Cider basting, spritzing route. Alot of butter leaves a mess in the bottom of the rack. The best way to make gravy with the drippings is to let them cool then use a fat separator. It makes a huge difference. I don't think I've ever had Thanksgiving Turkey basted with butter. Thankfully Turkey reigns supreme as according to a number of food historians the majority of meat was likely venison, with alot of mussels, clams, and maybe even lobster on the table.
 
Let's say deep frying is not going to happen (I know it is good, I just don't want to deep fry something that big). Let's also say you don't cut your turkey and roast / bake the breast and legs separately. You are most likely going to baste it with butter under the skin / on the breast, and tent it to avoid drying out, right?

So, I've seen people using cheesecloth to keep the turkey moist by self basting / pulling the juice back to the turkey, or use like 1lb of butter to baste it initially. Either way you end up with a lot of butter + turkey fat at the bottom of the pan. Do you use that dripping to make gravy? or refrigerate to remove the grease but keep the gel / juice for stock? Is there a way to baste a turkey without using butter? (I don't like the smell of too much butter on turkey, and that might be one of the reason I am not always a fan of thanksgiving turkey but ok with deli turkey)
My mother never used butter and I've never made a turkey. I think she used olive oil and eventually moved to a roasting bag.

When making gravy you're supposed to use a fat strainer and toss the fat.

K1012362800-2T.png
 
Cook that bird breast down, seriously. Don't knock it till you try it!
So, if you cook the bird up side down on a loaf of ciabatta, do you toss it away afterward? It has soaked up all the fat / butter / juice so it would kind of be a waste. But if you eat it, how do you prep it so it taste good? Stuffing?
 
The best thing about making a pie is greasing the pie pan with butter before the crust. Using your fingers, it's for sure a ButterFinger moment!!!!!
 
Let's say deep frying is not going to happen (I know it is good, I just don't want to deep fry something that big). Let's also say you don't cut your turkey and roast / bake the breast and legs separately. You are most likely going to baste it with butter under the skin / on the breast, and tent it to avoid drying out, right?

So, I've seen people using cheesecloth to keep the turkey moist by self basting / pulling the juice back to the turkey, or use like 1lb of butter to baste it initially. Either way you end up with a lot of butter + turkey fat at the bottom of the pan. Do you use that dripping to make gravy? or refrigerate to remove the grease but keep the gel / juice for stock? Is there a way to baste a turkey without using butter? (I don't like the smell of too much butter on turkey, and that might be one of the reason I am not always a fan of thanksgiving turkey but ok with deli turkey)
Let's get the terminology right. Injecting butter or similar under the skin is a marinating technique. Applying fat/oil/meat juice topically is called basting.

Is your goal to make dry turkey flesh more succulent? Have you tried brining? Have you tried landing a turkey? These are questions.

Larding is a technique that consists of making small incisions into the carcass and inserting thin strips of lard called lardoons with a tool called a larding needle. While the meat is roasting the lardoons will render and moisten the dry flesh. You can insert the lardoons into the flesh or under the skin.

I don't find turkey worth my time. I vastly prefer chicken or other game birds.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom